为智能体而设计:Zeno Rocha 谈打造 Resend

Designing for Agents: Zeno Rocha on Building Resend

泽诺·罗查 Zeno Rocha · Latent Space · 2026-11-10 · 约 86 分钟 · 原视频 ↗

打开互动全文版(中英对照 + 朗读 + 问答)→

本期速览 · Overview

Resend 创始人 Zeno Rocha 讲述开发者优先的邮件平台如何做到 430 万用户和 1000 万美元 ARR。

Resend founder Zeno Rocha shares how a developer-first email platform reached 4.3 million users and 10 million ARR.

要点 · TL;DR

核心观点 · Key points

反共识 · Contrarian takes

本期章节 · Chapters(共 26)

全文 · Full transcript(中英对照)

介绍与Resend的增长势头 Introduction and Resend's Traction

Zeno

就像,天哪,我们怎么可能打败 SendGrid?这简直不可能。然后今年早些时候,我们的下载量超过了 SendGrid,我当时就想,这太疯狂了。现在我们是他们的两倍多。所以截至今天早上,Resend 正在为 430 万用户提供服务。我们有各种各样的客户,比如华纳兄弟、HBO。最近有一个日本帮派来了,他们在 Resend 上注册了大概 2 万个域名。那是 2 万个不同的顶级域名,在不同的域名注册商那里注册的。我们是一家 ARR 1000 万美元的公司。我宁愿活在那个现实里,也不愿活在一个我们是 1 亿美元公司、但我女儿不想和我玩、她对我没兴趣、我们关系不那么亲密的现实里。所以我们正在构建基础设施,现在正深入到最底层。但这是一个大项目。我们已经工作了好几个月,很快会宣布一些相关的东西。

It's like, oh my gosh, how are we ever going to beat SendGrid? It's just impossible. And then earlier this year we crossed the number of downloads from SendGrid, and I was like, that's insane. And now we're more than double. So Resend now is powering 4.3 million users as of this morning. We have all sorts of customers like Warner Brothers, HBO. There was a Japanese gang that recently came. They brought like maybe 20,000 domains at Resend. Like those are 20,000 different TLDs registered in different domain registrars. And we are a 10 million ARR company. I would rather live in that reality than live in a reality where we are a 100 million dollar company and my daughter doesn't want to play with me. She's not interested in me and we're not that close. So we are building the infrastructure and going down to the metal now. But it's a big project. Like we've been working for months now and we're going to announce something soon about that.

Host

好的,我们在演播室和 Resend 的 Zeno Rocha 在一起。你我相识于你做 VS Code 主题的那些日子。

Okay, we're in the studio with Zeno Rocha from Resend. You and I go back to your VS Code theme days.

Zeno

是的。

Yes.

Host

那时你还只是个独立黑客,我当时就想,老兄,我不知道这家伙是做什么的,但他做的每件事都很有品味。然后现在你建立了一个电子邮件基础设施平台。总之,欢迎。

When you were just an indie hacker and I was like, man, I don't know what this guy does, but everything he does has taste. And then now you've built an email infrastructure platform. Anyway, welcome.

Host

你太谦虚了,不只是独立黑客。你是 GitHub 上最活跃的前 20 名,2022 年。非常非常活跃的开源开发者。

You undersell just the indie hacker. Top 20 most active GitHub under 20 20 22. Very very active open source dev.

Zeno

是啊是啊。

Yeah yeah.

Host

你通常怎么介绍自己?现在。

What's your typical how do you introduce yourself these days?

Zeno

是的,我觉得很长一段时间里我只是专注于我最近的职业生涯。即使今天我说,哦,我创建了 Dracula,人们知道 Dracula 比知道 Resend 更多,但是的,这很好。就像,是的,情况在改变。

Yeah, I think I just focus on my recent career for the longest time. Even today when I say like, oh, I created Dracula, people know Dracula more than Resend, but yeah, but it's been nice. Like there's a yeah, it's changing.

Host

是的。我想选择电子邮件领域的动力是什么?你知道,我觉得人们总是有像 React Email 和所有那些东西。我只是不,我会把它做成一家公司,你知道。

Yeah. What was the impetus for I guess picking email? You know, I think you know, people always have like obviously react email and all those things. I just don't I would have made it a company, you know.

Zeno

如果我知道电子邮件有多难,我可能也不会开始这家公司。

If I knew like how hard email is, I probably wouldn't start the company either.

Host

是的。你主要是做 JavaScript 前端 CSS 的工作吗?

Yeah. Were you a primarily JavaScript front-end CSS job like

Zeno

我是个前端家伙。HTML5 家伙,你知道?我觉得有趣并吸引我的是,我看着周围所有的工具,我以前都用过,Mailgun、Mailchimp、SendGrid 这些。我一直觉得,天哪,应该有一些东西,应该有人关心这个领域。我就是这么觉得的。你有所有这些玩家。这是一个巨大的市场,很多竞争对手,但没有人关心开发者这个角色。也许他们关心营销人员、产品经理或其他什么,但不是为了开发者。所以我开始围绕这个前提构建:如果这是电子邮件领域的 Stripe,它会是什么样子?是的,我对电子邮件一无所知。我是电子邮件的用户,但我从未构建过电子邮件管道和所有那些基础设施。

I was a front-end guy. HTML 5 guy, you know? And I think what was interesting and what drew me to it is like I just look at all the tools around that and I've used all of them before, the Mailguns, the Mailchimps, the SendGrids of the world. And I've always felt like man, there should be something where there's just some someone should care about this space. That's that's how I felt. Like you have all these players. It's a massive market, a lot of competitors, but no one that cares about the developer persona. Maybe they care about the marketer, the product manager, or whatever, but not for the developer. So I started just building around that premise of like if this was the the stripe of email, how would that look like? And yeah, that like I had no idea or knew nothing about email. Like I was a user of email, but I have never built like an email pipeline and and all that infrastructure before.

Host

是的,我的意思是,你知道,通常如果你问我,Postmark 还在。但然后显然 SendGrid 和所有这些家伙。他们还在,但也许不像一个新的 YC 创业公司那样创新,试图成功。首先,我喜欢让人们吹嘘一下。你能为从未听说过 Resend 的人,谈谈你最引以为豪的数字、标志或任何东西吗?

Yeah, I mean like you know, typically if you ask me like Postmark was still a thing. But like and then and then obviously SendGrid and all these all these guys. They're still around, but like they're not maybe as innovative as someone who's like a new YC startup like trying to trying to make it. Just to just upfront, I like to let people brag a bit. Can you like for people who never heard of Resend, what are like the the ways that you talk about like the most impressive numbers, logos, anything?

Zeno

是的。所以截至今天早上,Resend 正在为 430 万用户提供服务。我们有各种各样的客户,比如华纳兄弟、HBO。所以有真正的大客户,有各种需求,但也有很多独立黑客和只是建网站、建自己应用的人。是的,我们刚刚突破了 12 万付费客户。是的。

Yeah. So Resend now is powering 4.3 million users as of this morning. We have all sorts of customers like Warner Brothers, HBO. So customers that are really big and have all sorts of demands, but also a lot of indie hackers and folks who are just building a website, building their own application. And yeah, we just crossed 120,000 paid customers. And yeah.

Host

无尽的标志墙。

endless logo wall.

Zeno

是的,大标志墙。

Yeah, the big logo wall.

Host

这有效吗?是的。

this is effective? Yeah.

Zeno

炫耀。就是这样。

flex. There you go.

Zeno

你知道吗?一开始,我觉得我只是需要一些社会证明。然后最后,我想,你知道吗?这实际上挺酷的。老实说,我就像在一个随机的周六发现了华纳兄弟这样的公司。呃,那是在 AI 之前。所以我会去我的数据库,我想,哦,让我看看我能把谁放在网站上。我就做了你能做的最天真的事。比如让我看看域名。让我按 .com 过滤,按小的过滤。然后有这个域名,WBD,华纳兄弟探索。我不知道 wbd.com 是什么。然后我想,哦不,华纳兄弟在用我们。所以是的,我只是喜欢展示客户,是的。

You know what? Like in the beginning, I felt like I just need to have some sort of social proof. And then in the end, I was like, you know what? This is actually pretty cool. And I honestly like I found companies like Warner Brothers just like on a random Saturday. Uh I was just this was before AI. So I would go to my database and I'm like, oh, let me see who can I put on the website. And I just I did the most naive thing you can do. Like let me look at the domains. And let me just filter by .coms and filter by the small ones. And there was this domain, WBD, Warner Brothers Discovery. I didn't know what is wbd.com. And I was like, oh no, Warner Brothers is using us. So yeah, I just love featuring customers and yeah.

Host

具体对听众说,我联系这次采访的原因之一,第一,你知道,我应该 upfront 声明我是天使投资人。呃,当你给我发备忘录时,它超级简单。你说,看,呃,Mailchimp 已经退出,Postmark 已经退出,SendGrid 在 Twilio 旗下,谁在做这个?我说,好的,是的,似乎是对的。老实说,就我收到的推介而言,我已经投资了大约 30 多家公司。那是最直接的事情之一。然后第二,我,是的,我不喜欢添加 API 密钥,对吧?我喜欢把所有东西放在一个平台上,一个 API,一个 API 密钥覆盖一切。所以呃,Cloudflare 有内置电子邮件。我有一个项目,我设置了我的 Cloudflare 电子邮件域名、DNS、所有那些垃圾,DKIM,什么的,对吧?我不懂所有那些字母汤的东西。我已经设置好了。然后我想,好吧,我想添加另一种电子邮件东西。该死的模型说你必须添加 Resend。我想,谁,已经有 Resend 了,你知道,即使我已经设置了 Cloudflare 电子邮件,它仍然推荐它。它现在在屏幕上。

Specifically for listeners, one of the reasons I reached out for this interview, one, you know, I'm I should declare up front I am an angel. Uh when you sent me the memo, it was super simple. You're like, look, uh Mailchimp has exited, Postmark has exited, SendGrid is under Twilio, who is doing this? And I was like, okay, yeah, seems seems right. Honestly like in terms of like the the pitches I get, I've invested in about like 30 plus companies. That was like one of the most straightforward things ever. And then secondly, I yeah, I don't like to add API keys, right? Like I like to have everything on one platform, one API one API key to cover everything. So uh Cloudflare has built in email. And I had a project and I set up my Cloudflare email domain, DNS, all that junk, the DKIM, what have you, right? I don't know all the alphabet soup stuff. And I already had this set up. And then I was like, okay, well, I want to add another sort of email thing. Bloody model said you must add Resend. And I'm like, who the There's a Resend that like, you know, even already I have a Cloudflare email set up and it's just still recommending it. And it's on the on the screen now.

Host

这是他在赞美,就像,我不需要 Resend,但你想让我继续添加 Resend。

This is him praising and like, I don't need Resend, but you want me to keep adding Resend.

Host

是的,那么好吧,你贿赂了 OpenAI 和 Anthropic 的谁,让 Resend 出现在那里?

Yeah, so okay, who did you bribe in OpenAI and Anthropic to get Resend on there?

Zeno

哦,天哪,我希望有个人可以贿赂,因为是的,我肯定会付钱给他们。但我个人确实花了很多时间在这个话题上。就像我觉得每一代人,这就是为什么我一开始对构建这个东西如此感兴趣。就像每一代人都有定义那个时刻的工具,对吧?我们记得 Heroku 的日子。我是说 nullify per cell。你知道,所以对我来说,是的,有空间容纳新一代,而这一代不会像以前那样在同样的地方分发。所以从一开始我就非常专注,好的,当有人问起那个时,我们必须是第一。是的。

Oh man, I wish there was someone to bribe because yeah, I'll definitely be paying them. But I do personally spend a lot of time on that topic. Like that's something that I feel like every generation that that's why I was so interested to build this thing in the first place. Like every generation you have those tools that define that moment, right? We remember the Heroku days. I mean nullify per cell. You know, and so to me it was like yeah, there's room for a new generation and this new generation is not going to be distributed in the same places that it was before. So since the beginning I was like very focused on okay, we got to be number one when someone asks about that. Yeah.

介绍与邮件挑战 Introduction and Email Challenges

Host

你们在 60% 以上的时间里都被推荐为第一俱乐部代码。我觉得看看你们的策略会很有趣。你是怎么赢的?嗯,我确实想回到正题,你说过你对电子邮件一无所知,如何开始做电子邮件。我认为很多人实际上并不了解构建这样的服务需要什么,对吧?你可能因为已经搭建过所以知道。有些人只会想,好吧,我可以用 Twilio,我可以用 SendGrid,我可以用你们,但制作一个只是批量发送电子邮件的工具需要什么?人们没有考虑到什么?

You're very number one club code recommending 60% plus of the time. I think it'll be fun to see the playbook. How do you win that? Um I do want to get back into okay, so you said you had no idea why email, how to start email. I think a lot of people actually don't understand what goes into making a service like this, right? Uh you might cuz you've set it up. Some people would just you know, okay, I can use Twilio, I can use SendGrid, I can use you guys, but what goes into making a tool to just mass send emails? What do people not think about?

Zeno

是的,你可以做很多不同的事情,因为进入收件箱,尤其是当你进行大量发送时,与扩展一个应用不同,后者可以通过投入 GPU 或垂直/水平扩展来解决。对于电子邮件,你必须遵守游戏规则,Gmail 的行为与 Outlook 不同,与 Yahoo Mail 也不同,这个行业很有趣,因为它非常老派,并且很大程度上依赖联系人。但我们早期发现,我们对这个领域一无所知,所以从这种极其天真的视角出发是发生过的最好的事情。老实说,这是最好的事情,因为没有先入为主的观念什么是对什么是错。例如,对于他们来说,每个应用你进去首先看到的是一个表格,你必须填写关于我们要发送多少电子邮件、数量、你想做什么。然后你经过人工验证过程。两天后,他们接受或拒绝你。大多数时候他们会拒绝你。我当时想,这说不通,对吧?为什么要阻止人们?所以我知道我要完全消除这种摩擦,摩擦将由我们承担。我们会解决这个问题。当然,现在进入这个业务三四年了,我明白他们为什么这样做。到处都是欺诈和网络钓鱼和滥用。我不太公开谈论这个,但我们在内部构建了各种疯狂的系统来应对。但回答你的问题,如何架构这个?例如,当你向 10 万人发送电子邮件时,如果你只是向 Gmail 扔 10 万封电子邮件,Gmail 会限制电子邮件,因为太多了,他们想看到参与度。所以你要做的是,他们看到,好的,人们在打开电子邮件吗?人们在归档、立即删除还是不互动?好的,根据这些初始互动,然后我将如何处理其余的电子邮件将决定那个开始。所以你可以做聪明的事情,将 10 万人中最活跃的受众成员放在队列的开头。你必须把它放在队列中。你需要这是一种艺术和科学,你必须间隔每批发送。所以也要在不同提供商之间间隔。是的,现在我们购买不同的 IP 块。你必须查看 IP 块的历史,将人们分配到不同的 IP 池,然后随着时间的推移平衡 IP 池。所以这是一个疯狂的基础设施游戏。

Yeah, there's just a lot of different things you can do because landing on the inbox, especially when you're doing high volume is different from like when you're scaling just like an app where you throw GPU at the problem or you just scale more vertically or horizontally, whatever it is. With email you got to respect the rules of the game and how Gmail behaves is differently from Outlook and differently from Yahoo Mail and it's an industry that is fascinating because it's so old school and it relies a lot on contacts. But what we found early on was like okay, we know nothing about this world and so coming from this perspective like extremely naive was the best thing that ever happened. Uh like honestly like it was the best thing because like there's no preconception of what is right, what is wrong. So for them, for example, every single app you go and then first thing you see is like this form that you got to fill out about like how many emails we're going to send, what's the volume, what are you trying to do? And then you go through a human verification process. Two days later, they accept you or deny you. Most of the times they're going to deny you. And I was like, this doesn't make any sense, right? Like why are we blocking people? So I know I'm going to remove that friction completely and the friction will be on us. We're going to figure that out. Of course, now four years, three years in into this business, I get it why they do that. There's just so much fraud and phishing and abuse across the board. I don't talk too much publicly about that, but we build like all sorts of crazy systems internally for that. But to your question, like how you architect that? Like for example, when you're sending an email to 100,000 people, if you just throw 100,000 emails like to Gmail, what Gmail will do is they're going to throttle the emails because it's way too much and they want to see the engagement. So what do you do is like they see like, okay, are people opening the emails? Are people archiving, deleting right away or not interacting? Okay, depending on those initial interactions, then what I'm going to do with the rest of the emails will dictate that beginning. So there clever things you can do where 100,000 people put the most engaged audience members in the beginning of that queue. You have to put that in a queue. You need to it's an art and a science where you got to space out each batch. So and space out between the different providers too. And yeah, now we're like buying different IP blocks. You got to look at the history of the IP blocks, distributed folks into different IP pools, and then balance the IP pools over time. So it's a whole crazy infrastructure game.

Host

这能有多自动化,还是仍然有很多人工判断?

How automated can that be or is there a lot of human judgment still?

Zeno

是的,肯定有很多自动化。我认为随着时间的推移,我们了解到,对于新客户,我们可以以这样的速度发送。当然,如果你发送更多,也许你可以发送得更快,但我们必须进行节流以保护你作为发送者。所以 Gmail 和所有这些参与者希望看到的是一个持续发送越来越多的图表,而大多数人的做法是,你向大量受众发送一次,然后再也不发送,然后空着,然后突然又发送。

Yeah, it's a lot of automation for sure. And I think over time we learned that okay this is how fast we can send for new customers. Of course if you're sending more then maybe you can send faster but there's a throttle that we have to do to protect you as a sender. So like what Gmail and all these players will want to see is like a graph that is consistently sending more and more versus what most people do which is like you send once to a big audience and then you never send again and then it's empty and then boom you send it again.

Host

每周一次,每周两次?

On a once a week, twice a week?

Zeno

是的,那些是滥用者会有的模式,对吧?所以关于电子邮件营销和一般电子邮件的整个思维方式是,你需要做滥用者不会做的事情。是相反的。那么滥用者会做什么?他们购买域名。我们现在有一个日本团伙最近出现。他们最近带来了大约 20,000 个域名,这些是在不同注册商注册的 20,000 个不同顶级域名,我们检查每一个因素。所以他们来了。这是一个两天前购买的域名。所以非常新的域名会得到坏声誉。然后你看网站。它返回 200 还是基本的东西?有些人甚至不设置那个,或者他们做一个相似的域名。所以他们会想,哦,也许我会为代码外展做另一个域名。那很糟糕,因为看起来像你在钓鱼,对吧?因为你使用了一个看起来相同的域名。所以所有这些小事情,他们只是同时发送大量电子邮件,然后再也不发送。所以你必须逆向工程网络钓鱼如何工作,并构建一个完全相反的平台。

Yeah and those are patterns that an abuser will have, right? So the whole way of thinking about email marketing and in email in general is you need to do exactly what an abuser wouldn't do. It's the opposite of that. So what does an abuser do? They buy a domain. We have now like there was a Japanese gang that recently came. They brought like maybe 20,000 domains at recent like those are 20,000 different TLDs registered in different domain registrars and we look for every single factor there. So they come in. It's a domain that was bought two days ago. So very new domains they get bad reputation. Then you look at the website. Is it returning 200 or basic things like that? Some people don't even set that up or they do like a look alike domain. So they're like oh maybe I'll do another domain for code outreach. That's terrible because it looks like you're phishing, right? Because you're using a domain that looks like the same. So all these little things and they just do they send a lot of emails all at once and then they never send again. So you kind of got to reverse engineer how phishing works and build a platform that does exactly the opposite of that.

Host

你们有清单吗?或者你建议人们去一些知名的清单?

Do you have a list somewhere or do you recommend people go to some well-known lists?

Zeno

是的,我学到的是另一件我不知道的事情。电子邮件是需要大量教育的领域,但人们不感兴趣学习,对吧?平台应该为他们做所有这些事情。所以我们在产品中添加了洞察,这样人们可以直接应用洞察。所以我们查看发送模式,现在有了 AI 也很酷。我们有链接检查器和拼写检查器,所有这些检查器在你发送之前。所以是的,这是你教育受众的混合,但同时产品需要做教育。你越能融入最佳实践,越好。所以一个例子是,当你发送电子邮件时,你可以发送 HTML 版本和纯文本版本。很早我们就想,你知道吗?整个世界在变化。有更多的智能体比之前。让我们自动生成每封电子邮件的纯文本版本。我们可以从 HTML 中提取 markdown,然后发送。所以我们开始自动发送,这大大提高了送达率。你知道,垃圾邮件过滤器直接查看内容而不必解析要容易得多。所以那些我们想,哦不,让我们融入产品,大多数人不这样做,但我们想,这有道理。

Yeah what I've learned is again another thing I didn't know. Email is the type of world where it requires a lot of education, but people are not interested in learning, right? Like the platform should do all those things for them. So we added like insights inside the product so people can just apply the insights. So we look at sending patterns and now with AI is pretty cool too. Like we have link checkers and spell checkers, like all these checkers in before you send. So yeah, it's a mix of your teaching your audience, but at the same time the product needs to do the teaching. And the more you can bake in the best practices, the better. So one example too, when you send an email, you can send an HTML version and a plain text version. Very early on we were like, know what? Like this the whole world is changing. There were more agents than before. Let's just generate auto generate the plain text version of each email. We can extract from the HTML the markdown and then just send that. So we started sending that automatically and that increased deliverability a ton. You know, it's so much easier for spam filters to just look at the content directly without having to parse that. So those things that we were like, oh no, let's bake into that product and most people don't do that, but we were like, that this makes sense.

Host

但是纯文本没有跟踪,对吧?因为你不能嵌入图像。

But with plain text there's no tracking, right? Because you can't embed the image.

Zeno

没错。

That's right.

Host

所以你没有打开率。

So you don't have open rates.

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

邮件送达率与追踪 Email Deliverability and Tracking

Host

如果没有打开率,你怎么知道你的邮件有送达率?

How do you know you have deliverability if you don't have open rates?

Zeno

是的,这很有意思,因为行业里有两种追踪方式,对吧?有打开追踪和点击追踪。打开追踪会包含一个 1x1 的 GIF 图片,一个透明图片。然后如果那个图片被加载了,你就检测为打开。问题在于,苹果最近在透明度和数据隐私方面做的所有改变,比如他们在邮件落地前就读取邮件,如果他们做摘要之类的事情。所以打开率作为一个指标整体上并不像以前那么可靠了,因为所有这些垃圾邮件过滤器都在之前检查。所以你就依赖点击追踪。现在点击追踪也可能很困难,因为你希望 URL 与发送域名匹配。你还希望图片 URL 与发送域名匹配。这是滥用者的另一种模式。他们会把图片托管在别处,把链接指向别处,然后从这些域名发送。

Yeah, this is very interesting because in the industry there are two ways of tracking, right? You have open tracking and click tracking. Open tracking includes a one-by-one GIF image, a transparent image. And then if that image is loaded, then you detect that as open. The problem with that is that all the changes that Apple did recently in terms of transparency and data privacy, like they read the emails before it lands if they are doing the summaries and all those kinds of things. So the open rate as a metric as a whole isn't really as reliable as it used to be because all these spam filters are checking that before. So then you rely on click tracking. Now click tracking can also be difficult because you want the URLs to match the sending domain. You also want the image URLs to match the sending domain. That's another pattern that an abuser will do. They would host images somewhere else, point links somewhere else and then they are sending from these domains.

Host

我感觉我用过一些邮件服务会重写链接追踪,对吧?他们会重写到自己的域名。你说那不好?

I feel like I have used email services that would rewrite like for the link tracking, right? They would rewrite to their own domain. You're saying that's bad?

Zeno

那不好,因为发生了什么,我们一开始也那样做了。

That's bad because what happened we did that too at first.

Host

我以为那很正常。

I thought that's normal.

Zeno

是的,但不好的是你也有一个吵闹邻居问题,如果使用点击追踪的客户中有一个是滥用者,发送了一堆钓鱼邮件,那个域名可能会被列入黑名单,然后可能需要几天或几周才能从黑名单中移除。

Yeah, but what's bad is when you have a noisy neighbor problem too where if one of the customers using that click tracking is an abuser and sends a bunch of phishing, that domain might get listed on a blacklist and then it takes maybe days or weeks to get out of the blacklist.

Host

那你作为企业就完蛋了。

Then you're screwed as a business.

Host

很常见?比如你让注册非常容易,免费套餐,发送一堆邮件。我会假设你有很多垃圾邮件,很多钓鱼邮件,

Pretty common? Like you make it very easy to just sign up, free tier, send a bunch of email. I would assume you have a lot of spam, a lot of phishing,

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

但你能够避免,这就是原因?

but you're able to avoid and this is why?

Zeno

是的,我觉得对我来说不同之处,这更像是一种哲学,对吧?所以我看到那些其他产品以及它们的行为方式,我觉得好吧,这几乎就像如果你出生在一个社会,你先去监狱,然后你必须在监狱里待 18 年,你必须证明你是一个好公民,然后你出狱了,现在你可以做你想做的事情。我一直觉得不,我想生活在一个我生来自由的社会,如果我犯了错误,那么我可能只会受到一点惩罚,或者如果我做了真的很糟糕的事情,会受到严厉的惩罚,对吧?所以我对那个也是这种感觉。比如你进来,我们默认信任你。当然,再次,一种天真的想法,但你知道吗?我们默认信任你,而不是因为那些坏人让整个平台对每个人来说都更糟,对吧?所以我们默认信任你,但我们与其他人的不同之处在于,在最初的那一刻,比如当我们注意到有些不对劲时,比如通过查看退信率、投诉率、我们从邮箱提供商那里得到的所有反馈,然后我们很快封锁你,然后我们和你聊天,我们试图理解,大多数时候只是误用,不是滥用。所以我们了解到我们需要区分。

Yeah, I think what was different to me and then this is more like a philosophy, right? So I saw those other products and the way they behaved and I felt like okay, it's almost like if you are born in a society where you first go to prison and then you have to spend like 18 years in prison, you got to prove that you are a good citizen and then you get out of prison and now you can do the things you want to do. I always felt like no, I want to live in a society where I'm born free and if I make a mistake, then I might be punished just a little bit or if I do something like really bad, a bad punishment, right? So that's how I feel about that too. Like you come in, we trust you by default. Of course, again, a naive way of thinking, but you know what? We're going to trust you by default versus make the whole platform worse for everyone because of those bad actors, right? So we trust you by default, but then what we do differently from others is like at the very first moment like when we notice something is off like by looking at the bounce rates, complaint rates, all the feedback we get from mailbox providers, then we block you like very quickly and then we chat with you, we try to understand and most of the times it's just misuse, it's not abuse. So we learned that we need to differentiate.

Host

技能问题。

Skill issue.

Zeno

是的,这是技能问题,没错。这是技能问题。

Yeah, it's a skill issue, exactly. It's a skill issue.

Host

我想我们了解到我们也有技能问题,不是吗?没想到。

I think we learned we have skill issues too, didn't we? Wouldn't have expected.

Host

是的,是的。电子邮件如此重要,又如此肮脏,如此隐秘,它就像——我几乎只想让你把一切都告诉我们。

Yeah, yeah. Email is so important and it's so dirty and it's so secretive and it's just such a I almost just want you to like just tell us everything.

Host

我会说你有一个有趣的页面。 literally 你所谓的哲学。我读着读着就迷失了,然后还有一个呼吁,你有一个承诺,你会让电子邮件更安全。就像如果你对这东西感兴趣,你知道,你这里有不少内容。

I will say you have a fun page. Literally your philosophy as you called it. I got lost just reading around this and then there's like a call you have a pledge that you will make email safer. Like if you're interested in this stuff, you know, you have quite a bit up here.

Host

嗯,好的,所以实际上我想说,这里有一个业余的技能支持。我觉得这让你想起我另一个投资,Railway 的 Jake。

Um okay, so actually I do want to there's this there's a hobby skill support there. I think this is this is a you remind me of another investment that I had Jake from Railway

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

因为也是另一个非常非常宽松、非常面向开发者的,但你也必须做技能支持,对吧?因为一旦有人被封锁,他们就会来找你说嘿,你知道,别把我踢出你的平台。

because also another like very very permissive, very developer oriented, but also you have to skill support, right? Because the moment someone gets blocked, they come to you and say hey like you know, don't kick me off your platform.

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

你如何做技能支持?

How do you skill support?

Zeno

天啊,我觉得如果支持是一个软件,我们可能在大版本四左右。就像第一个版本是

Man, I think if support was a software, we're probably on major version four or something. Like the very first version was like

Host

你?

You?

Zeno

是我,我压力太大了。我说兄弟,我只需要有人坐在椅子上。就这么简单。我不能再做这个了。而且就像任何人,任何人,我不在乎。然后你那样做,当然不会顺利,因为你很快意识到你需要一个真正试图防止工单发生的人。所以我们到了 V2,就像一个新区版本,我们最终雇了一个新人,就像,好的,我们在回答工单。他们有领域专业知识,但他们仍然没有做主动的工作,比如,不,让我们确保这在讨论之前被记录下来。所以我们设定的一项政策,实际上很酷,就是你只能用一个链接回复工单。所以你不能直接给出答案。你必须停下来写一篇知识库文章,写文档,然后所以你回答一个工单可能需要一个半小时,但你猜怎么着?现在你又在发送那个链接了。所以那超级酷,它帮助我们建立了那个知识库,但即使如此,在那之后当我们超过也许 100 万用户时,我们在 12 月有 100 万用户,现在我们有 400 万。所以我不能把人扔向问题,但那不会解决问题,对吧?就像我只是继续增加人员,就是这样。像不。所以我们真的必须重新思考,好的,一切从头再来。我们想保持那个免费套餐。不是我想摆脱那个免费套餐。我作为一名工程师开始,因为我能够使用那些免费产品,对吧?就像我们都一样,如果不是 Heroku 的免费套餐和所有其他产品,我们就不会在这里。所以我想保持那种方式,但我们花了很多次迭代才

me and I was so stressed out. I'm like dude, I just need someone to be sitting on the chair. Like it's that simple. I cannot be doing this anymore. And it was like just anyone anyone, I don't care. Then you do that, of course it doesn't go well because you realize very quickly you need someone that will actually try to prevent the tickets from happening in the first place. So then we went to V2 which was like a new version like a new person that we ended up hiring, that was like, okay, we're answering the tickets. They have domain expertise, but they were still like not doing the proactive work of like, no, let's make sure this is documented before we talk about. So one policy that we set, it was pretty cool actually, is like you can only respond to a ticket with a link. So you cannot just give the answer right away. You had to stop write a knowledge base article, write a docs, and then so it takes like an hour and a half maybe for you to answer a ticket, but guess what? Now you're sending that link all over again. Uh so that was super cool and it helped us build that knowledge base, but even so like after that we when we crossed maybe 1 million users, so we had 1 million users back in December and now we have four. So I can't throw people at the problem, but that's just not going to solve it, right? Like I'm just going to keep staffing and and that's how it is. Like no. So we really have to rethink like, okay, everything from scratch again. And we want to keep like that free tier. It's not I don't want to get rid of that free tier. I started as an engineer because I was able to use those free products, right? Like we all like if it wasn't for Heroku's free tier and all these other products like we wouldn't be here. So I want to keep reason that way, but it took us many iterations to

Host

是的。这其中有多少是,好吧,这是一个人们不太了解的领域。他们实际上是需要人工支持的独特问题,而不是,你知道,用 command K,你只要有文档,你有一个模型,

Yeah. How much of this is like, okay, it's a domain people don't know a lot about. They're actually unique questions that need human support versus, you know, command K with just you have docs, you have a model,

Zeno

嗯。

Mhm.

Host

客服机器人存在,对吧?

the customer service bots exist, right?

Zeno

是的。我觉得现在好多了。有几件事我和——有太多摩擦。DNS,天啊,就像总是 DNS。哦,总是 DNS,对吧?就像我们今天得到的大多数问题就是人们无法设置那个。

Yeah. I think right now is much better. There are few things where me and there's so much friction. DNS, oh my gosh, like that's always DNS. Oh it's always DNS, right? Like the majority of the questions we get today is just like people not able to set that up.

服务新受众 Serving a New Audience

Zeno

这很有意思,因为我们在服务一个新的受众,对吧?这个受众甚至不知道如何排查问题。就像我记得去年 Lovable、Bolt 和 v0 出现时,我能看出这些是不同的用户。他们遇到问题时不知道怎么办,就卡住了。他们不知道如何解决。而在 DNS 方面,情况一直如此,他们根本不知道什么是 CNAME、什么是 A 记录、TXT,该把这些放在哪里,所以他们可能会粘贴错误的值或犯傻。

And it's fascinating because we're serving a new audience, right? It's an audience that doesn't even know how to troubleshoot. Like I remember last year when Lovable came and Bolt and v0, I could tell these are different users. They don't know when they have a problem, they are stuck. They don't know how to go past that. And with DNS that was always the case, like they just simply don't know what is a CNAME, what is an A record, TXT, where do I put those things, so they would paste the wrong value or silly things.

Host

顺便说一句,现在我使用像 Codex 或 Claude Code 这样的计算机使用工具,它完全管理我的 DNS 记录。太棒了。

By the way, right now I use computer use like Codex or Claude Code and it just completely manages my DNS records. It's great.

Zeno

很美妙,对吧?

It's beautiful, right?

Host

它会调试,会像 dig 那样,你知道,尝试所有 DNS 相关的东西,我不用操心。

It debugs it, it like digs, you know, and tries all the DNS stuff like I don't have to worry about it.

Zeno

是的。我们做的一件事,我发现这个超级冷门的协议,业内很少有人投资。它叫 Domain Connect。顺便说一句,它非常有趣。它起源于一些域名提供商,然后

Yeah. One thing that we did, like I found this super obscure protocol that very few people in the industry were investing in. It's called Domain Connect. And it's super interesting by the way. And it's something that started from some domain providers and

Host

哦,对对对对,这就像是域名的 OAuth,对吧?

Oh, yeah yeah yeah yeah, this is like the OAuth for domains, right?

Zeno

没错。

Exactly.

Host

是的,这像是面向 Cloudflare 的。

Yeah, this is like Cloudflare oriented.

Zeno

所以有些人有 Cloudflare,然后我们说服 Vercel 也加入,我们开始聚集更多人。所以你有两边,对吧?DNS 提供商和服务提供商。例如我们是服务提供商,然后 DNS 提供商在实施。但这是一个非常疯狂的行业。就像 GoDaddy 为此收取很多钱。太奇怪了。就像 Ionos,我们花了几个月才找到那个人,好像没有人真正维护这个协议之类的,但很美妙,就像有一个协议,你可以直接为域名做 OAuth。

So some people have like Cloudflare is there, then we convinced Vercel to be there as well, and we started gathering more people. So you have the two sides, right? The DNS providers, the service providers. We are the service providers for example, and then the DNS providers are implementing. But it's a crazy crazy industry. Like GoDaddy charges just a lot of money for that. It's so weird. Like Ionos, it took us, the first one, it took us months to get after that person, like no one really maintains the protocol and things like that, but it's beautiful, like having a protocol that you can just do an OAuth for domains.

Host

是的。是的。所以对于听众,如果你不熟悉,如果你没试过,类似这样的东西,它就像你使用 Plaid 或 OAuth。你只需点击按钮,不用输入任何东西。没有什么会出错。你基本上只需登录。只要你信任这个叫 Domain Connect 的东西,你已经确认它是合法的,那么它就是可信的。我两周前第一次使用它。我当时想,这是什么?我以前从未见过。

Yeah. Yeah. So for listeners, if you're not familiar, if you haven't tried it, something like that, it is literally like you use Plaid or use like OAuth. You only click buttons, you don't type in anything. There's nothing to get wrong. You basically just sign in. As long as you trust this thing called Domain Connect, which you have confirmed that it is legit, then it's trusted. I literally used it for the first time like two weeks ago. I was like, what is this? I never seen this before.

Zeno

是的。所以真的很酷。我试图弄清楚的一件事也是你如何开始这家公司。就像你说的,你试图联系 Ionos 的那个人。我想我不敢在没有 Gmail 内部有人情况下开始 Resend。

Yeah. So it's really cool. One of the things that I'm trying to figure out as well is how you like start this company. Like you said, you tried to get in touch with the Ionos guy. I'm like I wouldn't dare to start Resend without knowing having like some guy on the inside at Gmail.

Host

即使是现在,就像,好吧,我们能 vibe code 我们自己的电子邮件东西吗?

Even now it's like, okay, can we vibe code our own email thing?

Zeno

显然不能,但即使有今天的工具也是如此。你几年前就这么做了。就像如果你知道,你想要域名注册商的人,你需要那个人,对吧?但是

Clearly no, but that's even with tools today. You did this years ago. Like if you know, you want people at domain res like you need the guy, right? But

Host

你现在需要拿起电话。

You need to pick up the phone right now.

Zeno

是的。有很多次我们不得不拿起电话。这很迷人。就像这是一个非常依赖关系的行业。我们没有那些关系,所以我们招聘了几个关键职位,比如送达率相关的职位,那些从一开始就在 Postmark 或 15 年前在 Mailchimp 工作的人。然后我们利用那个网络。但是的,这很疯狂。但现在有趣的是,当然我开始时不知道。就像我永远无法预测会发生什么。

Yeah. There were many times that we had to pick up the phone. It's fascinating. Like it's an industry that relies on relationship a lot. And we didn't have those relationships, so we hired for a few key roles, like deliverability roles, folks that have been at Postmark since the beginning or 15 years ago at Mailchimp. And then we leveraged that network. But yeah, it's pretty crazy. But what's interesting now, of course I didn't know that when I started. Like I could never predict what was going to happen.

Host

没做研究?

Didn't do the research?

Zeno

是的。不。就像我永远无法预测,好吧,AI 会做什么等等,对吧?但我认为我们处在一个空间,我很高兴我们选择了基础设施。我很高兴我们是基础设施即服务,而不仅仅是软件即服务。

Yeah. No. Like I could never predict like, okay, what AI was going to do and all that, right? But I think we are in a space where me and I'm glad we chose infrastructure. I'm glad we're infrastructure as a service and not just yeah, software as a service.

Host

你有一点,对吧?你前一年做了 React Email。所以你确实涉足了开源工作。

You had a little bit, right? You had You made React Email the year before. So you did dip your toes in open work.

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

然后公司就来了。

And then came the company.

React Email策略 React Email Strategy

Zeno

是的,React Email 是我们的 Next.js,对吧?所以我们想要一个开源渠道作为漏斗顶部。我记得有意做了一些事情。例如,如果你去文档,你会找到关于如何与 SendGrid、Mailchimp 和 Mailgun 设置的文档。我写了那里的每一份文档。我只是想,好吧,这是给所有人的,我们试图重新定义这是如何,这是一个策略,就像我们要给予、给予、给予,然后我们要求。如果人们

Yeah, React Email is our Next.js, right? So we wanted an open source channel for top of the funnel. And I remember doing some things very intentionally. If you go to the docs, for example, you'll find their docs about how do you set this up with SendGrid and Mailchimp and Mailgun. I wrote every single one of those docs over there. And I just wanted like, okay, this is for everyone and we're trying to redefine how this is and it was a strategy of like we're going to give, give, give and then we ask. And if people are

Host

Gary V 那套?

The Gary V?

Zeno

是的,如果人们使用 React 构建电子邮件模板,现在他们需要一个平台来发送它。他们在哪里做?这就是 Resend。所以这是一种讲故事的方式来接近市场。就像我们要修复旅程的第一部分,即构建模板。然后一旦你有了模板,现在那个问题解决了,你需要一个平台来发送它。这是平台。

Yeah, and if people are building the email template using React, like now they will need a platform to send it. Where do they do that? Here's Resend. So it was a storytelling kind of way of approaching the market. Like we're going to fix the first part of the journey, which is building the template. And then once you have the template, now that problem is fixed, you need a platform to send it. Here's the platform.

Host

但是当你开始 React Email 时,你有 Resend 的想法吗,还是它是一个副项目然后变成了公司?

But did you have the idea for Resend when you started React Email or was it a side project that then became a company?

Zeno

是的。我们开始了 Resend,当我们构建 Resend 时,我做了很多用户研究,人们说,哦,编写模板的痛苦。我从设计师那里拿到 Figma 文件。太糟糕了。就像 HTML 表格等等。

Yeah. We started Resend and as we were building Resend, I was doing a lot of user research and people were saying like, oh, the pain of writing the template. I get the Figma file from my designer. It sucks. Like it's HTML tables and everything.

Host

他们会切图,对吧?

They would cut the images, right?

Zeno

是的。天哪。因为什么都没有。

Yeah. Oh my god. Because there's nothing.

Host

然后有一种特殊的 HTML 语法只在电子邮件上有效,

And then there's like a special syntax of HTML that only works on email,

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

对吧?或者 CSS?都是内联 CSS。

right? Or CSS? It's all inline CSS.

Zeno

是的,内联 CSS。没错。然后对于 Outlook,你有一些特殊注释,然后你必须 太乱了。就像一团糟。

Yeah, inline CSS. That's right. And then like for Outlook, you have like some special comments and then you got to It's such a mess. It's like a it's a mess.

Host

所以对我来说,React 能工作的原因是它基本上是一个编译器。就像有人写一次,然后只要你符合 API,它就会在任何地方工作。

And so like to me, the reason that React works is that it is basically a compiler. It's like well, somebody writes this once and then as long as you fit the API, it's going to work everywhere.

Zeno

是的。你可以从 Tailwind 导入你的令牌。现在你有 TypeScript 的类型定义。所以不再有嘿空逗号,你知道,就像在你的电子邮件上。你可以实际上有字符串验证或任何你想要的。

Yeah. And you can import your tokens from Tailwind. Now you have a type definition with TypeScript. So no more hey empty comma, you know, like on your emails. Like you can actually have a string validation or whatever you want.

Host

我认为最初反对 React Email 的人之一是说,好吧,你实际上没有使用 React。没有状态。

I think one of the initial people that pushed back on React Email is like, well, you're not actually using React. There's no state.

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

就像 React 应该是视图作为函数状态。但所以它主要是 JSX 是模板,还是有实际的动画?有交互性吗?

Like React is supposed to be a views as a functional state. But so it's mostly JSX is templating or is there actually like animations? Is there interactivity?

Zeno

没有。

No.

Host

展开像手风琴。没有那样的?

Expanded like accordions. Nothing like that?

Zeno

所以,你不能在电子邮件上发送 JavaScript。那么,你做的就是 是的,我们基本上使用模板。

So, you cannot ship JavaScript on an email. So, then what you do is Yeah, we basically use the templating.

Host

是图灵完备的,如果你

Is Turing complete if you

Zeno

好的,太酷了。

Okay, so cool.

向邮件先驱学习 Learning from Email Pioneers

Host

嗯,我其实很想继续聊邮件这个话题,但我看到了好多我以前认识的名字。我就是有点好奇,你能不能稍微满足一下我们,就聊聊其中一些名字,比如你从他们身上学到了什么,有没有什么有趣的故事,随便什么都行,你知道吧?

Um I actually do want to like continue on this email path, but I see so many names I used to know. I was just kind of uh wondering if you can indulge us a bit and just go through like some of these names like what you learned from them, if you have any like cool stories, if just just anything, you know?

Zeno

我学到了太多太多。嗯,我记得 Resend 的第一年,我当时想,我得见见 Mailgun 的创始人,因为我当时还是 Mailgun 的用户。我和 Ev 聊了聊。嗯,他建了……哦我的天。

Me and so much, so much. Uh I remember the very first year of Resend, I was like, I got to meet the founder of Mailgun because I was still a user of Mailgun. And I talked to Ev. Um he's he built Uh oh my gosh.

Host

Blogger?Medium?

Blogger? Medium?

Zeno

嗯,不是。是另一个产品。嗯,但不管怎样,他现在在做一个安全产品。我记得和他聊天时,我说,老兄,你为什么这么快就把公司卖了?到底是怎么回事?他告诉我,哦对,我们 90% 的研发都只是为了对抗滥用者。所以,那是个糟糕的生意。你不该往那走。我当时就想,呃,我完全不想活在那个世界里。嗯,所以我非常担心这一点。嗯,这对我来说是个很大的教训:好吧,我们得把这东西自动化。我们绝不可能为此建立一个庞大的组织。我们现在确实有很多人对安全感兴趣,但那不会成为我们的核心业务。不,我们要推动行业前进。但那是其中一个。而 SendGrid 一直是我最喜欢的,一直是那个巨无霸,最大的,就像,哦我的天,我们怎么可能打败 SendGrid?这根本不可能。然后今年早些时候,我们的下载量超过了 SendGrid 的某个数字,我当时就想,这太疯狂了。现在我们是他们的两倍多。

Um no. It's a It's a different product. Um but anyways, like he It's a security product that that he's building now. And I remember talking to him. I was like, man, why did you sell so quickly your company? What was the thing? And he told me like, oh yeah, 90% of our R&D was just to fight abusers. So, it was a It's a terrible business. Like you shouldn't go there. And I was like, uh like I don't want to live in that world at all. Uh so I was very worried about that. Uh and it was a big lesson for me of like, okay, we got to automate this thing. Like there's no way we're just going to build like a massive org uh for We do have a lot of people interested in safety now, but it's not like that's going to be our core business. No, we're going to We have to be pushing the industry forward. But that was one. And SendGrid has always been my favorite out of those ones and always been the behemoth, like the the biggest, the It's like, oh my gosh, how are we ever going to beat SendGrid? It's just impossible. And then earlier this year, we crossed a number of uh downloads from SendGrid and I was like, that's insane. And now we're more than double.

Host

抱歉,是指

Sorry, in terms

Host

独立用户数,还是什么数字?

of unique users, or what's the what's number?

Zeno

SDK 的下载量。

downloads of the SDK.

Host

那是最好的指标吗?

Is that the best metric?

Zeno

是的。我觉得这个指标在采用率方面确实说明了一些问题,但如果你看他们发送的邮件数量,那显然比我们多得多,因为他们还有大企业客户之类的。

Yeah. Like I think there's there's something about that metric in terms of adoption, but then if you look at how many emails they sent is obviously much more than us because they have like the big enterprise customers yet and that kind of thing.

Host

我觉得有一件事很令人惊讶

I think one thing that's surprising

Zeno

嗯。

Mhm.

Host

是 Twilio 收购 SendGrid 的重点在于,你现在不再是一个邮件服务了。你是一个通信平台,对吧?你整合了一切。这不仅仅是交叉销售。而是我可以通过多个渠道触达你,之类的。或者是你有规模,你知道,Twilio 现在市值多少我不知道。我们就说它是 130 到 150 亿美元的公司吧。

is the whole point of the Twilio SendGrid acquisition is that I now you are no longer an email service. You're a communications platform, right? You you integrate across everything. It's not it's not just about cross sell. It is about I can reach you across multiple channels, something like that. Or that you have the size, you know, Twilio is like I don't know what the size is now. Let's call let's call it 13 15 billion dollar company.

Zeno

嗯哼。

Uh-huh.

Host

呃,你应该拥有所有关系、所有人才、所有这些东西,对吧?那你怎么和那样的对手竞争?

Uh you should have all the relationships, all the talents, all these all these all these things, right? So how do you compete with that?

Zeno

是啊。老兄,我非常钦佩 Twilio。他们某种程度上发明了 DevOps,或者说

Yeah. Man, I I admire Twilio so much. They kind of invented DevOps or or or like

Host

你的开发者。

your developer.

Zeno

你知道,“问问你的开发者”。而现在,当我经过 101 公路那块广告牌,看到“客户 AI”之类的,我就很生气。我就想,为什么?你忽视了你成功的原因。嗯,我觉得现在 Jeff 也不在了。CFO 是

you know, ask your developer. Like and now when I I I I I go past that 101 billboard and I see a customer AI or whatever, I'm pissed. I'm like, why? Like you neglected the thing that got you there. Um and I think now like Jeff is not there anymore. The CFO is

Host

买了洋葱报。

bought the onion.

Zeno

对,没错。没错。所以我觉得他们就是在这上面睡着了。他们先是对 SendGrid 这样,现在对 SMS 也是这样。嗯。

Yeah, that's right. That's right. So I feel like they're just sleeping on it. And first they did that with SendGrid and they're doing that with SMS too. And yeah.

Host

但我觉得我在这里的教训是,我试图弄清楚这个行业的规模经济学,对吧?很明显,你知道,我们就说他们比你刚起步时大 100 倍,对吧?嗯,为什么他们不能利用自己的规模直接赢?对吧?所以换句话说,也许规模并没有好处。也许你只需要,你知道,你只需要做出更好的产品,然后你就可以慢慢

But I I think my my lesson here is I'm trying to figure out the economics of scale of this industry, right? Like clearly, you know, let's let's call it they're 100 times larger than you when you when you just got started, right? Um how come they cannot use their size to just win? Right? So so in in other words, maybe maybe there is no benefits to scale. Maybe you just, you know, you just make a better product and you can slowly

Zeno

当然。我也一直在想,为什么是 Twilio 收购了 SendGrid,而不是反过来?

For sure. And I I've always thought about too like why did Twilio acquire SendGrid and not the other way around?

Host

我觉得 Twilio 更大。我是说,SMS

I think Twilio was bigger. I mean, SMS

Zeno

是啊。

Yeah.

Host

很大。

is is big.

Zeno

但就像邮件和通信是商品一样,SMS 的利润率更薄,甚至更糟。所以

But like if email and communication is a commodity, like SMS, your margins are even slimmer, even worse. So

Host

你有没有研究过 SMS?

Have have you looked into SMS?

Zeno

当然有。

Yeah, for sure.

Host

SMS?

SMS?

Zeno

我觉得总有一天。是的,我觉得总有一天。是的。

I think one day. Yeah, I think one day. Yeah.

Host

哪些渠道重要?邮件、SMS,还有什么?

What are the channels that matter? Email, SMS, what else?

Zeno

在很多国家都很大。

is big in in many countries.

Host

你不用付任何钱。

You don't pay anything.

Zeno

是的,但然后你得通过 Meta,现在商业消息要收费了。所以那里肯定有一些摩擦。

Yeah, but then you you got to go through meta and now business messages are going to be charged. So there there is some friction there for sure.

Host

电话呢?

Phone calls?

Zeno

电话是个好渠道。我没那么感兴趣。是的。

Phone calls is a good one. I'm I'm less interested. Yeah.

Host

接到任何机器人电话,对吧?

take any robo calls, right?

Zeno

没错。我对那个也没那么感兴趣。我关心的是,什么能让我与我的受众建立联系?那才是我最终关心的。我不关心邮件本身。

that's true. I'm less interested about that too. What I care is like what are the things that makes me able to connect with my audience? Like that's what I ultimately care. Like I don't care about email.

Host

私信。

DMs.

Zeno

是的,私信。那是一个。这很难,因为你不能给一大群人发私信,但 Slack 也许是一个,对吧?就像我有很多 Slack 联系人,我需要分享我们构建的这个新功能的消息。

Yeah, DMs. That's one. It's hard because you cannot like DM a big crowd like but Slack maybe is one, right? As you Like I have so many Slack connects and I need to share the news about like this one new feature that we built.

Host

Pylon,我不知道你们用不用 Pylon。我觉得他们创新了这种 Slack 支持的东西,但你显然可以轻松自己构建。好的,然后我想谈的另一个是 AWS SES。

Pylon, I don't know if you guys use Pylon. I think they kind of innovated this like Slack support thing, but you can obviously trivially build your own. Okay, and then I think the other one I want to touch on is AWS SES.

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

所以我和这个的联系是,我通过 freeCodeCamp 跟 Quincy Larson 学编程之类的。

So my connection to this is I learned to code with free code camp with Quincy Larson and everything.

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

他们的新闻简报有大约 500 万订阅者

They have like 5 million subscribers on the newsletter

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

通过 Amazon SES 发送,每月大约 5000 美元。

sent through Amazon SES for like $5,000 a month.

Zeno

嗯。

Mhm.

Host

这很便宜。

Which is cheap.

Zeno

便宜。

Cheap.

Host

我不知道你们会收多少钱。

I don't know how I don't know what you will cost.

Zeno

是的。比那多。

Yeah. More than that.

Host

所以基本上对我来说,它就是个低成本玩家,对吧?我是说,它是亚马逊,他们超级成熟。你从他们那里学到了什么,然后人们应该知道什么来避开他们?

So so basically like to me it's just like the low cost player, right? That is I mean it's Amazon, it's like they're they're super established. What do you take from them and then what do you what should people know to stay away from them?

Zeno

我们也是从 SES 开始的。我们知道,好吧,如果我们要在这里创新,我想在开发者体验(DX)层创新,因为我觉得那是个服务不足的领域。所以,让我为每种语言都提供 SDK。我记得在 Serverless 方面,我们突出了服务,因为没有人有关于如何用 Lambda 发送邮件的指南之类的。所以,DX 领域就是有这个服务不足的空间。所以我们从最高层开始,这对我们非常有效。我们能够扩展,因为我们在后台使用 SES。结果发现,在域名的结构方式上有很多限制,他们有配置集的概念。而如果你用 SES,隐藏成本是,好吧,你可能只付 5000 美元,但现在你需要 SNS 来处理事件。

We started with SES too. We knew that okay, if we're going to be innovating here, I wanted to innovate on the DX layer and because I felt like that was the underserved uh space. So, let me have SDKs for every single language. I remember with Serverless, we highlighted service because like no one had like guides on how to send an email with Lambda or something. So, there's just this underserved space in DX. So, we started with like the most high-level layer and that served us really well. We was able to like scale because we were using SCS behind the scenes. Turns out there's just a lot of limitations when it comes to the way you structure domains and they have this concept of configuration sets. And the hidden cost if you're going with SCS is that okay, you might be paying only 5K for example, but now you need SNS for the events.

基于SCS构建还是深入底层 Building on SCS vs Going Down to the Metal

Zeno

所以,你需要所有反馈,比如退信、投诉、打开点击等等。现在你拿到了事件,很好。现在你需要 CloudWatch 来记录日志。现在你需要一个队列,因为会有大量事件。所以,现在你添加 SQS。有了 SQS 之后,你开始添加所有这些不同的层。哦,你想要 webhooks?好吧,现在你得再建一个东西。所以,如果你用 SCS,它是一个很好的平台。它没问题,但你会注意到你的足迹会很快变得比你想象的大得多,因为你需要周围所有的装置。

So, you need all the feedback from bounces, complaints, open clicks, all that. And now, so you get the events, great. Now you need CloudWatch for the logs. Now you need a queue because it's going to be a lot of events. So, now you add SQS. And now that you have SQS, you start adding all these different layers. Oh, you want webhooks? Okay, now you got to build another thing. So, if you go with SCS, it's a great platform. It's fine, but you're going to notice your footprint will be much bigger than you would imagine very quickly because you need all the apparatus around it.

Host

是的。嗯,我想说,你知道,另一个在邮件领域出现的 YC 初创公司是 Agent Mail。

Yeah. Um I would say, you know, another YC startup that came up in the mail area is Agent Mail.

Zeno

是的。

Yep.

Host

然后他们,我也和那个人谈过,他说,是的,我们不打算,我们会在 SCS 之上构建,而不是真正与他们竞争。

And then they I talked to the guy as well and it was like, yeah, we were not going to we're going to build on top of SCS and not really compete with them.

Zeno

是的,但对我们来说,现在情况变了。所以,我们正在构建基础设施,现在正深入到金属层。对我们来说,感觉我们已经到了这样一个点:现在在最基础的层面上创新是有意义的。现在如果我们专注于这一点,我们可以获得更好的吞吐量、更好的送达率。呃,但这是一个大项目。我们已经工作了几个月,我们很快会宣布一些事情。

Yeah, but for us it's changing that now. So, we are building the infrastructure and going down to the metal now. And for us it feels like we got to the point where now this makes sense to innovate on the most basic layer. And now we can get better throughputs, better deliverability if we just focus on that. Uh but it's a big project. Like we've been working for months now and we're going to announce something soon about.

Host

最难的事情是什么?是可信 IP 吗?是数据中心的算力吗?还是什么阻碍?

What what is the hardest thing to Is it like trusted IPs? Is it compute in data centers? Or what is the blocker?

Zeno

是的,绝对是 IP。你买下整个 IP 块,然后现在你自己管理 IP 池。这是一点。然后你几乎在做流量控制,控制进入每个邮箱提供商的吞吐量。然后你需要与提供商的关系。但是一旦你建立了这些基础设施,你现在可以更好地控制你能提供给用户的东西。所以我的最大事情之一是可观测性,你知道,作为一名工程师,我想确切地看到发生了什么,我一直觉得在这个领域没有足够的信息。比如一旦邮件发出,它真的送达了吗?它真的在垃圾邮件文件夹里吗?在促销标签里吗?我从来不知道。你只是相信邮件发出去了。然后你总是听到一些用户说,哦,我没有收到邮件。我就想,什么?发生了什么?所以这些事情之间存在空白。我们越接近金属层,我们就有越多的数据可以呈现给用户。所以我真的很兴奋。这就像我们正在做的旗舰级改变。

Yeah, definitely the IPs. You're buying like a whole IP block and then now you're managing the IP pools yourself. That that's one. And then you're almost doing like traffic control and you're controlling the throughput into each mailbox provider. And then you need the relationships with the providers. But then like once you have that established that infrastructure now you have way more control into what you can give to users. So one of the my biggest things were like observability, you know, like that as a engineer I I want to see exactly what's happening and I've always felt like in this space there wasn't enough information. Like once when an email goes out, is it really delivered? Is it really on the spam folder? Is in the promotional tab? Like I never know. Like you just trust that the email goes out. And then you always hear from some user like, oh, I didn't get the email. I'm like, what? Like what happened? So there's that empty space between those things. And the more we're close to the metal, the more we have in terms of data that we can surface for for users. So I'm really excited. It's like the flagship change that we're making out to

Host

我的意思是,你正在成为,这对所有 DX 类型的业务来说真的很有趣。你从一个薄层开始,比如 react email,然后就像,好吧,我们会在别人的基础设施上构建。然后一旦你有了规模,你就可以真正构建自己的基础设施,对吧?因为现在你拥有了一切,你在做什么不同的事情吗?

I mean, you're becoming it's it's really interesting for all like DX type businesses. You start with like a thin layer like a react email and then it's like, okay, well, we'll build on other people's infra. And then once you get size, then you can actually build your own infra, right? Are you doing anything differently because now you own everything?

Zeno

是的,我认为我们正在做的是嗯

Yeah, I think what we're doing is um

Host

顺便说一句,显然你的仪表板很漂亮。

And by the way, obviously your dashboards are beautiful.

Zeno

有趣的是,老兄。现在和我交谈的每个人,所有客户都说,哦,我从来没有打开过仪表板。但我们稍后可以谈这个。但有趣的是,我花了那么多时间试图让那个仪表板漂亮,现在人们不去那里了。这有点令人沮丧,但我理解。但是的,我们只是试图用我们处理所有其他问题的同样天真的心态来处理这个问题,我们说,好吧,这不应该是这样的。所以你在挑战最基本的事情,比如这不应该是这样的。P99 不应该花这么长时间。我们如何让它更快?好的,所以这就是我们现在正在做的事情之一,非常深入地关注性能,我们一直是一个 Node JS 商店,我们到处都用 TypeScript,最近在发送路径上我们不再使用 JavaScript。我们在那里用了 Go,我们正在改变其他部分,以在其他方面更高效。

It's funny, man. Everyone I talk to now, like all the customers are like, oh, I never opened the dashboard. But we can talk about that later. But it's interesting. Like I spent so much time trying to make that dashboard beautiful and now people don't go there. It's kind of frustrating, but I get it. But yeah, we're just trying to approach that with the same naive mentality uh that we approached all the other problems and we're like, okay, this shouldn't be this way. So you're challenging the most basic things of like this shouldn't be this way. The P99 shouldn't take this long. How we can make it faster? Okay, so that's one of the things we're doing now like focus very very deep into performance and we have always been like a Node JS shop and we have like just TypeScript everywhere and most recently like in the sending path we no longer use JavaScript. We have go there and we're changing other parts to be more more performant in other ways.

Host

因为现在语言不重要了。

cuz now languages don't matter.

Zeno

完全正确,对吧?现在太便宜了,是的,比如选一个问题,是的,你可以用任何最快的语言重写整个东西。

Exactly, right? It's just so cheap to yeah, like pick a problem and yeah, you can rewrite the whole thing in whatever the fastest languages.

Host

我就像在运行 Rust 项目,但我从来没有,我真的不懂 Rust。就像我知道一些关于 Rust 的理论知识,但我从来没有真正费心去学它。我觉得我们没有真正覆盖最近的产品表面区域。是的,呃,也许你想继续。

I'm like running Rust projects and I've never I don't really know Rust. Like I know like some theoretical things about Rust, but I've never really bothered to learn it. I I feel like we are not really covering the recent product surface area. Yeah, uh maybe you want to go.

Zeno

不,不,我的意思是,你知道,我们已经谈过的一切,这就是为什么它很难,你正在解决的所有问题,然后还有从 CLI 发送邮件,超级代理转发。你对此有一些看法。我想前几天你发推文说 MCP 回来了,对吧?就像超过一百万次 MCP 调用,那么电子邮件的 AI 方面是什么?

No, no, I mean, you know, there's everything we've talked about which is why it's hard, what all you're solving and then there's also just send emails from CLI, super agent forward. You have some takes on this. I think the other day you tweeted like MCP is so back, right? Like over a million MCP calls like what's the what's the AI side of email?

Host

是的,每个人都说 MCP 死了,对吧?几个月前,就像,是的,唯一重要的是 CLI。我注意到的是,我不再关注什么流行,什么不流行,我真的思考这些问题,比如,好吧,我希望我的产品是什么样子?嗯,我希望我的产品是无形的。无论他们想用产品做什么,都应该可能。所以这就是为什么我们一直是 API 优先。你知道,我没想到这对我们以后会有多大帮助,但我知道,是的,就像我永远无法覆盖所有用例。所以让我只提供 API,你做你想做的。而 MCP,真是令人着迷,每个月至少 2 倍增长。现在在八月份,这些数字甚至更多。这是八月底之前。我想结束时是 120 万。但是的,就像人们开始从 Claude Desktop 或 Codex 工作。如果工作从那里开始,那么你需要那些集成,对吧?这非常重要。

yeah, everyone was saying MCP was dead, right? A couple months ago like yeah, the only thing that matters is the CLI. What I've noticed is that I stop paying attention to what what's in, what's out and I I really think about these problems is like, okay, how do I want my product to be? Well, I want my product to be formless. Whatever they want to do with the product it should be possible. So that that's why we've always been API first. You know, I had no idea how much this would help us down the line, but I knew yeah, like if I will never be able to cover all the use cases. So let me just give the API, you do whatever you want. And with MCP, it's just fascinating like every month, like at least 2x growth. And now in August, these numbers are even more. This was before the end of August. I think it was 1.2 million by the time it ended. But yeah, like people are starting to work from Claude Desktop or Codex. And if work starts from there, then you need those integrations, right? It's just super important.

Host

我只想澄清一下。所以你知道,你给我们展示了 MCP 事情的逐月数字。它从比如 50% 的月环比增长开始,这已经非常高了。然后它开始基本上每个月翻倍。你们对 MCP 进行了投资,还是只是有一个 MCP,然后过了一段时间它就被采用了?

I just want to clarify as well. So you know, you you showed us sort of like the month by month numbers on the MCP thing. It picked up from like let say 50% month over month growth, which is already super high. Then it starts to double basically every month. Did you do investment into MCP or you just had an MCP and you just after some time it gets picked up?

Zeno

嗯,有趣的事实是,我们的第一个 MCP 是由我们的投资者 A16Z 的 Yoko 构建的。

Well, the fun fact about that, our very first MCP was built by Yoko from A16Z, our investor.

Host

哇,增值。

Wow, value add.

Zeno

是的,对吧。所以她构建了开源版本。它是一个远程的本地 MCP。然后它开始疯狂增长,我就想,天哪,为什么人们在使用,设置 MCP 这么难。这是去年的事。然后

Yeah, right. So she she built the the open source version. It was a remote a local MCP. And and then it started to grow like like crazy and I was like, man, why are people using It's like so hard to set up MCP. This was last year. And then

Host

Yoko。

Yoko.

Zeno

是的,没错。所以她构建了那个。然后我只是问她,嘿,你能转移到我们的组织吗?就像只是一个工程师在构建东西。看到它获得关注后,这很好。

Yeah, exactly. And so she built that. And then I just asked her, hey, can you transfer to our org? It was like just like an engineer building something. And it was nice to see after the traction it was getting.

构建远程MCP与OAuth Building Remote MCP and OAuth

Zeno

但要把 MCP 做对,尤其是远程版本,我们必须回头重新审视整个权限模型,因为我们需要 OAuth。然后我们说,好,现在有阻碍了,来构建 OAuth 吧。于是我们构建了 OAuth,然后说,好,OAuth 回来了,来看看这个,看看用户如何访问每个资源。所以构建 OAuth 是一段完整的旅程。有了 OAuth 之后,好,现在我们有远程 MCP 了。然后就是分发。所以现在有了远程 MCP,好好好,可观测性也到位了,好好,所有 Datadog 仪表盘都好了,现在全部就绪,去和大家谈谈吧。那也很难,没那么容易。我希望我有你所有的人脉。没那么容易

But to do the MCP right, to do the remote one, we had to go back and revisit our entire permissions model because we needed OAuth. And then we were like, okay, now we have a blocker. Let's build OAuth. So then we build OAuth and it's like, okay, OAuth back. Let's look at that. Like let's look at how users have access to each one of the resources. So it was a whole journey to build OAuth. And then after we had OAuth, okay, now we have the remote MCP. And then it's distribution. So then, okay, now we have the remote MCP. Okay, great, great, great. Observability is in place. Great, great. Okay, all the Datadog dashboards. Okay, now all in. Let's talk to everyone. And that was hard too. Like it's not as easy. I wish I had all your connections. It's not as easy to

Host

对我来说。你随时可以找我聊。

to me. You can just want to talk to me.

Zeno

但比如和实验室谈,试着进入官方商店和插件市场之类的。

But like talking to the labs and trying to get into like the official stores and plugin marketplaces and all that.

Host

那真的重要吗?

Actually matters?

Zeno

哦,当然。

Oh, for sure.

Host

是的,所以我觉得有时候我也在另一边,我拼命去争取这些合作,我们发布了,然后什么也没有。对吧?

Yeah, so I think sometimes like I've been on the other side where I try so hard to get these partnerships. We launch it and then nothing. Right?

Host

哪一个重要?

Which one matters?

Zeno

所以作为消费者,我现在做决定是基于我是否能访问那个数据。作为 B2B 软件的买家,如果我去云连接器,看不到那家公司以官方 MCP 列出——比如我们之前用 Plausible 和 PostHog。Plausible 有一个由 Century 构建的 MCP。我不在乎。如果 Plausible 不维护它,那不是官方的,我就不能那么信任它。尽管我喜欢 Century 团队,信任那个团队,但我需要软件的所有者也拥有这个集成部分。

So as a consumer, I make decisions now based on do I have the access to that data or not? So as a buyer of B2B software, if I go to the cloud connectors and I don't see the company listed there with an official MCP like for we had this like we had a we were using plausible and PostHog. Plausible had an MCP built by Century. I don't care. If the plausible doesn't maintain that and that's not official, I cannot trust that as much. Even though I love the Century team and I trust that team, but I need the owner of the software to own this piece of integration too.

Host

天哪。

God.

Zeno

我做了决定,不,我们要弃用 Plausible,就用 PostHog,因为那里有 MCP。作为 B2C 消费者我也这么做。我喜欢跑步,然后我想,哦,让我用 Strava。Strava 有 MCP,我可以访问我的跑步记录。所以我用 Strava 就是因为这个。所以如果有比如,哦不,我们有 MCP,但你得这样连接,比如 X 的 MCP,我得用本地版本,那太令人沮丧了。它在桌面客户端能用,在我手机上不能用。对我来说就是,如果它不在那里,我就不用。

And I made the call like, no, we are getting rid of plausible and we're just going to use PostHog here because I have the MCP there. And I did that as a as a B2C consumer too. I'm like into running and then I'm like, oh, let me like Strava. Strava has an MCP. I can like access my runs. So I use Strava because of that. So and if there's like, oh no, we have an MCP, but you have to connect like this like the X MCP for example. I have to do like the the local one. It's just so frustrating. It works on the desktop client, not on my phone. Like like to me is just yeah, if it's not there, I don't use it.

何为优秀MCP What Makes a Good MCP

Host

除了它由供应商官方维护之类的,什么让一个 MCP 好,而另一个一般?

Apart from okay, it is officially maintained by the vendor or whatever, what makes a good MCP versus a so-so MCP?

Zeno

即使在我与之交互的几个小时里,我总是……它总是崩溃,对吧?我总是在打开那两个调用,试图理解它做了什么。就在几天前,有一个调用因为某种原因无法把所有内容放到联系人上,然后我说不,这不应该发生。我们发送了多少数据?也许我们向客户端发送了太多数据。所以我注意到的是工具的数量——这 earlier 是个更大的担忧,比如哦如果你有太多工具我会困惑。我现在不那么看到了,事实上我们只是在向 MCP 添加更多。

Even for hours as I as I interact with that there were I always like it's always collapse, right? The two calls I'm always opening and trying to understand like what did it do? And just a couple of days ago like there was one call where it couldn't put everything on the contacts for some reason and then I'm like no, this shouldn't happen. Like how much data are we sending? Maybe we're sending way too much data to the client. So that's something that I noticed like the amount of tools this was a bigger concern earlier like oh if you have way too many tools I get confused. I don't see that as much anymore and in fact we are just adding more to the MCP.

Host

哦。

Oh.

Zeno

比如我们发布时可能有,我不知道,20 个工具,甚至更少,现在我们有 80 多个工具。

Like we had like maybe I don't know 20 tools when we launched or even less than that now we have like 80 something tools.

Host

什么

What the

Zeno

是的,而且我在添加越来越多,就像长尾的……我注意到的是足迹,比如你只能做到仪表盘功能的 90%,这是一种方式;或者你可以做到 100%,达到仪表盘功能的 100% 覆盖实际上非常非常困难,因为现在你要做用量、账单、团队邀请、账户配置、删除,这些应该作为 API 暴露吗?这真的很难,是个困难的问题。

Yeah and like I'm adding more and more like the the long tail of two of like the the footprint that's what I've noticed like you can do like only 90% of what your dashboard does and that's one way of doing it or you can do 100 getting to 100% coverage of what your dashboard can do is actually very very difficult cuz now you're doing usage, billing, team invites, account provisioning, deletion, should that be exposed as an API or not? Like it's it's really hard like it's a it's a difficult problem.

API设计与Next.js API Design and Next.js

Host

是的,事实上你知道你是我能与之谈论这个的少数嘉宾之一。我认为这是 Next.js 的错误之一。

Yeah in fact you know you're one of the few guests that can I can ever talk about this with. I think this is one of the mistakes on Next JS.

Zeno

哦真的吗?

Oh really?

Host

因为 Next.js 和服务器组件以及 pages API 或 app API 它们让你很容易基本上将数据绑定到页面

Because Next JS and server components and pages API or app API they make it easy for you to basically bind data to your page

Zeno

好的。

Okay.

Host

所以你从不暴露公共 API。

so you never expose a public API.

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

所以默认情况下,出于性能考虑,他们鼓励你做的,你就不会有 API,对吧?然后你就得做单独的代码路径之类的。

So by default the thing that is performance and they encourage you to do you will not have an API, right? Then you have to just do like separate code paths or whatever.

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

事实上你应该总是有一个完全无头的后端,然后你的前端只是连接到后端的众多客户端之一。

In fact you should just always have like completely headless back end and then your front end just happens to be one of many clients that connects to your back end.

Zeno

是的,我们最初在 Next 上做 API。我记得首先账单太高了,我们说不可能付得起。所以我们转向传统的 Node 服务器,服务器四,随便你怎么叫。然后我们的仪表盘一直像是一个私有 API 消费同样的东西。我们不得不重复很多代码。一团糟,对吧?现在好多了。所有东西在一个 monorepo 里,你可以重用东西,但是的,理想情况下那些框架默认就给我们那些组件,对吧?我们不得不单独构建一个公共 API,维护两者很糟糕。

Yeah, we started with uh our API on Next. I remember that first of all, the bill was just so high that we were like there's no way we can pay for this. So then we moved to a traditional node server uh server four, whatever you call it. And and then like our dashboard was always like a private API consuming the same thing. We had to duplicate a lot of code. It was a mess, right? Um now it's so much better. Everything on a mono repo, you can reuse stuff, but yeah, like by default ideally those frameworks like just gives us those components, right? We had to build a public API separately from that and it sucks to maintain both.

工具数量与反馈 Tool Count and Feedback

Host

是的。好的,然后还有一件事,你知道,所以你有 80 个工具,还在增加更多工具。你非常反共识,相比 Cloudflare 只有两个工具,你的搜索和执行之类的。

Yeah. Okay, and then one more thing about just so uh you know, so you are you got 80 tools in there, you're growing more tools. You are very counter consensus compared to Cloudflare which only has two tools, your search and execute or something like that.

Zeno

嗯。

Mhm.

Host

到目前为止你还没感觉到那个问题,但什么会让你改变主意,对吧?好像数字在上升,但你真的知道吗?你和客户谈过,他们说,天哪,这是地球上最好的 MCP,或者

So far you haven't felt that issue, but uh what would make you change your mind, right? Like you you it seems like numbers are going up, but do you actually know? Do you do you talk to your customers and say they're like, oh my god, it's like the best MCP on earth or like

Zeno

嗯。我确实试图获得很多反馈,然后我喜欢构建产品的方式是我得自己用产品,对吧?比如我昨天发给你的投资者更新,那是用 MCP 构建的,你知道?它从一处获取数据,从另一处获取数据,然后

Mhm. I do try to get a lot of feedback on that and then the way uh the way I like to build products is I got to use the product my on on my own, right? So if I'm like the investor update that I send you yesterday, that was built using the MCP, you know? It was like fetching data from one place, from another place, and then uh

Host

你现在让我感觉不好。我听到的基本上是我用 MCP 不够。

You're making me feel bad now. I don't use MCP enough basically is what I'm hearing.

Zeno

我,我的意思是另一件事也是,你有 CLI,你有常规 SDK,那些也疯了吗?一切只是来自大量增长还是

Me I mean I guess the other thing is also like you do have CLI, you do have regular SDK like are those also just going crazy? Is everything just from a lot of growth or

CLI与SDK增长 CLI and SDK Growth

Zeno

是的,CLI 肯定在增长,但不如 MCP 那么多。但我也在 CLI 上有很多乐趣。比如如果你去我们的招聘页面,我实际上为此感到自豪,因为我在周末之类的时间构建了它。但如果你去那里的任何职位并尝试申请工作。你知道,现在也有 go down。你有三种申请方式。你可以或者 API。所以你可以直接登录,它有一个交互模式,或者我们在 CLI 中内置了技能,你可以直接问 Claude,比如申请 Recent 的产品设计师职位。

Yeah, the CLI is definitely growing, but not as much as the MCP. But I have a lot of fun with the CLI too. Like if you go to our careers page, I'm actually proud of this because I built it on a weekend or something. But if you go to any job there and you you try to apply for a job. And you know, there's also go down now. You have three ways of applying. You can or API. So you can just log in and it has an interactive mode or we have skills baked in into the CLI and you can just ask Claude like apply for a product designer role at Recent.

CLI作为求职筛选 CLI as a Job Application Filter

Host

你这是在用垃圾填充自己,尤其是在招聘方面,但不对,我的意思是,也许那也正是你想要的人,对吧?

You are filling yourself with slop, especially in careers, but no, I mean I think maybe that's also the people you want, right?

Zeno

完全正确。我其实有一个筛选标准。如果来源是 CLI,我会另眼相看,因为我知道人们是在多走一步,比如设置这个,就像“哦不,我得下载这个东西,我得认证,然后我得走完那个流程”。但你猜怎么着?经历过这些的人总是告诉我:“老兄,我以前从未用 CLI 申请过工作。”所以即使他们没被录用,也有一种不同的体验,与其他工作申请不同。

Totally. I actually have a filter. If the source is the CLI, I look differently because I know people are going the extra mile like setting that up like oh no, I got to download this thing and I have to authenticate and then I have to go through that flow. But guess what? Like people who go through that, they always tell me like man, I've never applied for a job using a CLI before. So even if they are not accepted, like there's just something like it's just a different experience than other job applications.

Host

甚至 API。通过 API 申请一份工作。

Even API. Apply for one job through API.

Zeno

我的意思是,这和 CLI 是一回事。呃,是的,所以我认为我也在试图弄清楚的一件事是产品哲学,对吧?就像你显然在每个地方都最大化,比如每个 SDK、每种语言、每个界面。显然用智能体更容易,但我想我认识的一些其他创始人会说:“嘿,这无关紧要。交给 Greenhouse 或 Ashby 吧。”

I mean it's you know the same thing as the CLI. Uh yeah, so so I think one of the things that I'm trying to figure out as well is like product philosophy, right? Like you you are you clearly just like you just max everywhere, like every SDK, every language, every surface area. Obviously easier with agents, but I think some other founders that I would know would say hey, this doesn't matter. Give that to Greenhouse or Ashby.

Host

是的。

Yep.

Zeno

这是你的工作,你不会这样区分,对吧?

It's your job you're not going to differentiate like this, right?

Host

是的。

Yeah.

Zeno

你显然有一种非常不同的哲学:你关心一切,即使你知道其中一些东西可能只是浪费。

You clearly have a very different philosophy of you care about everything even though you know it's probably some of this stuff is just wasted.

Host

我的看法是,嗯,我试图优化的不仅仅是特权用户,比如那些拥有最好 Wi-Fi 的用户,在旧金山或纽约用 MacBook 的人,对吧?还有所有那些处于边缘、在其他国家、Wi-Fi 很差的人。

The way I see it is um I'm trying to optimize not only for the privileged users, like the users who are who have the greatest Wi-Fi, the MacBooks that are here in SF or in New York, right? All these people at the margins that are in other countries with a terrible Wi-Fi.

Zeno

巴西。

Brazil.

Host

巴西。我成长过程中就是这样。一台糟糕的 Windows 电脑和糟糕的互联网接入。所以这就是为什么我们有免费层。我们不是无缘无故有免费层的,你知道,背后是有原因的。当我们拥有所有 SDK 时。所以我在 SDK 上最大化。天哪,构建 .NET SDK,你觉得那有趣吗?比如我们研究了

Brazil. Growing up that that's how it was for me. A terrible Windows computer and terrible internet access. So that's why we have the free tier. We we don't have the free tier because of the you know like there's a there's a reason behind it. When we we have all the SDKs. So I'm maxing on the SDKs. Man building the .NET SDK, do you think that was fun? Like and we looked into

Zeno

Stainless。

Stainless.

Host

Stainless、Fern,第三个是什么?呃,但我们看了所有这些公司,对吧?我们不喜欢生成出来的东西。所以每一个 SDK 都是人工生成的。Java 的、呃 Rust 的,所有那些,对吧?我这样做是因为我觉得,是的,如果你在使用一个产品,你应该在你使用的语言中获得最佳体验。哦,但 400 万人中只有 500 人。我关心那 4400 人。

stainless, fern, what's the third one? Uh but like we look at all these companies, right? We didn't like what was generated. So every one of those SDKs is humanly generated. The Java one, uh Rust, all those ones, right? And I do that because I feel like yeah, if you're using a product you should have the best experience in that language that you're using. Oh, but there's only 500 people out of the 4 million. I care about those 4 400 people.

Zeno

哇。

Wow.

Host

你知道吗?为什么不呢?你知道吗?

You know? Why not? You know?

Zeno

为什么不呢?因为你有 400 万用户。这就是为什么不。

Why not is you have 4 million users. That's why not.

Host

有很多事情要做,但你知道。

A lot of stuff to do but you know.

Zeno

在构建这个产品时,有那种有主见的一面是好事,对吧?

It's it's good to have that opinionated side towards building this, right?

多人邮件与产品哲学 Multiplayer Email and Product Philosophy

Host

我们还有什么其他产品界面方面的事情应该涵盖吗?呃,你涵盖了 CLI、模板、MCP。

Any other product surface area stuff that we should cover? Uh you covered CLI, covered templates, covered MCP.

Zeno

我认为从你这里获得一个高层次的视角是好的,了解这其中有多少是非常传统的。你甚至有仪表板、手动编写电子邮件的模板。你有程序化的方式。你也有完整的智能体构建。比如你觉得它会走向何方?你如何思考为这个快速变化的世界构建这个产品,对吧?

I think it's good to get a high-level perspective from you of how much of this is very traditional. You even have dashboards, templates to manually write emails. You have programmatic. You also have the full agent build. Like where do you see it going? How do you think about building this for a pretty fast changing world, right?

Host

是的。电子邮件肯定还有一个组成部分,就是从这种单人模式转向更多人的多人模式。呃,我们甚至这样构建了我们的编辑器。它是多人协作的。如果你有两三个人,它能解决所有冲突。我们实际上运行——如果我有一个私人的 Recent 账户,与所有团队一起,呃,我们在那里举行所有全员会议。所以全员会议基本上就是你去那里。它是一个巨大的

Yeah. There's definitely still a component of email moving out of this single player mode and going more into multiplayer. Uh we even built our editor like this. It's multiplayer. It fixes all the conflicts if you have two or three people. We actually run if I have a private recent account with all the teams and uh we run all of our all hands uh there. So the all hands is pretty much you go there. It's a huge

Zeno

你做一个

You make an

Host

它是一封电子邮件,我们在全员会议结束时一起发送这封邮件。超级有趣。你有大约 20 个人在同一个文档里。

It's an email, and we send the email together at the end of the all hands. It's super fun. And you have like 20 people in the same document.

Zeno

这太——我觉得 99% 的人没有想过多人协作电子邮件,对吧?但是

This is so I I feel like 99% of people have not thought about multiplayer email, right? But

Host

是的。

Yes.

Zeno

你有很多。

You have a lot.

Host

是的。那真的很有趣。天哪,光是那个编辑器,维护它太难了,但我喜欢它。我喜欢我们为需要 UI 的人提供了 UI。比如有些团队讨厌把电子邮件模板推送到他们的源代码中,他们只想构建一个可视化编辑器,一个模板交给营销团队,然后只需调用 ID。我不管模板。我只想用变量调用 ID,然后就完成了。其他团队则说,不,我想提交。我想对此有源代码控制并拥有这部分。所以我试图针对那些不同的受众,构建一个让人感觉我们关心的产品,这是我在其他地方得不到的感觉。

Yeah. And it was really fun. Man, that editor alone, it's so freaking hard to maintain that thing, but I love it. I love that we have the UI for people who need the UI. Like some teams hate to have the email template pushed into their source code, then they just want to build a visual editor, a template give to the marketing team and just call the ID. I just I don't care about the template. I just want to call the ID with variables and I'm I'm done. Other teams they they they do like, no, I want to commit. I want to have source control over this and own this piece of thing. So I try to tailor to those different audiences and and build a product that feels that we care, which is not the feeling I get elsewhere.

邮件阅读与Agent收件箱 Email Reading and Agent Inboxes

Host

是的。顺便问一下,Recent 团队用什么读邮件?Superhuman 还是

Yeah. By the way, what does the recent team use to read email? Superhuman or

Zeno

是的。哦天哪,那个——你看到 Superhuman 上次更新了吗?你也忙于其他发布,对吧?

Yeah. Oh man, that Have you seen the last Superhuman update this You were busy with other launches too, right?

Host

是的。而且,对于听众来说,我们是在 Astro 发布当天录制的,我被拉进去了,我都没睡觉。但是,它有什么问题?他们只是稍微更新了 UI。

Yeah. And And for for listeners, we are recording this on the day of the Astro launch, which I was pulled into and like I am not sleeping. But no, what's wrong with it? They just updated the UI a little bit.

Zeno

是的,只是有一种情绪,就像,哦,这正朝着其他所有收购的方向发展,对吧?就像现在你在喂养一个还有其他利益的品牌。

Yeah, there's just the a sentiment of like, oh, this is going to the direction of every other acquisition goes, right? Like now you're feeding a brand that has other interests.

Host

和其他东西。

and other things.

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

好吧。只是电子邮件。我知道我确实想跟上电子邮件技术的总体发展。你在发送方,而人们在阅读和接收方。

Okay. It's just email. I I know I I do want to keep up to date on email tech in general. You're You're on the sending side of the people on the reading and receiving side.

Zeno

是的。

Yes.

Host

然后我认为,你知道,越来越多地我会说智能体在阅读我的电子邮件,对吧?我实际上不读大部分电子邮件。我有 Poke 和两个人类帮我处理电子邮件。

And then I think you know, increasingly I would say agents reading my email, right? I actually don't read most of my email. I have Poke and two humans helping me with my email.

Zeno

不错。我我那个。

Nice. I I that.

Host

Poke 挺

Poke is pretty

Zeno

好的。我老实说喜欢 Instinct 现在超级火。25 亿美元的公司没有收入。就像人们试图阅读电子邮件创新。

good. I I honestly like Instinct now super hot. 2.5 billion dollar company with no revenue. And like it's just like people trying to read email vations.

Host

是的。我们肯定在关注那个领域。这是我花很多时间的另一件事,比如你如何通过程序创建几十个收件箱,然后这些收件箱如何被智能体访问?

Yeah. That we are definitely looking to that space. That's another thing that I'm spending a lot of my time like how you can programmatically create dozens of inboxes and then how are those inboxes accessed by agents?

Zeno

你创建了你启用了接收电子邮件。它叫什么?Inbound?

you you create you enabled receiving email. What is it called? Inbound?

Host

是的。

Yeah.

Zeno

电子邮件。

Email.

Host

所以现在我们要进行另一个抽象。Inbound 就像是最基本的抽象。现在我们更进一步,就像,哦,你出于任何原因需要一百个收件箱。而这里是你在此基础上需要的 API,对吧?所以你需要一个读取 API、标记为未读,你需要星标 API、标签。

So now we're going another abstraction. Inbound is like the most basic abstraction. Now we're going one step further and be like, oh, you need a hundred inboxes for any reason. And here are the APIs that you need on top of that, right? So you need a read API, mark as unread, you need star API, labeling.

Zeno

我明白了。

I see.

Host

呃,所以我们很快会围绕这个推出一个产品。

Uh so we're going to be launching a product around that soon.

Zeno

是的,但再次强调,这一切都是 API 驱动的,因为那是——因为就像我会说,我一直在看的可比产品是 Missive。

Yeah, but again, it's all API driven because that's the the because like I I would say the comparable stuff that I've been looking at is missive.

Host

是的。

Yep.

Zeno

还有其他像 Help Scout

And there's other like Help Scout

Host

是的。

Yes.

邮件市场份额 Email market share

Host

就像共享收件箱那类产品,对吧?Front?

Like a shared inbox type of product, right? Front?

Zeno

Front。对,希望这个能成为那种产品的版本。我可以分享给你。如果你想试试,有个功能开关可以给你开。

Front. Yeah, so hopefully this can be a version of that. I can share with you. There's a feature flag for you if you want to try that out.

Host

对,我对邮件技术非常感兴趣。好。然后对我来说,我又一直在问这些问题。你的邮件有多少百分比是发到 G Suite 的,或者说市场份额是多少,对吧?比如 Google 对比 Outlook 对比 Apple 对比 Hotmail?

Yeah, I'm very interested in email tech. Okay. And then to me and then again, I'm just like asking all these questions. What percent of your email goes to a G Suite or you know, like what's the market share, right? Like Google versus Outlook versus Apple versus Hotmail?

Zeno

我手头没有具体数字,但绝大多数,至少 60% 是 Gmail。然后后面大概有三大,比如 Outlook、Yahoo 邮件之类的紧随其后。然后还有长尾的

I don't have the numbers top of my head, but the vast majority like at least 60% Gmail. And then you have like maybe the big three after like the Outlook, the Yahoo mails of the world right after. And then you have a long tail of

Host

Apple 没那么大。

Apple is not that big.

Zeno

Apple 挺大的。对。尤其是他们现在搞的隐私功能,就更难了。

Apple is big. Yeah. And especially with the privacy thing that they did now, it's harder.

Host

注册到

Sign up to

Zeno

一个 Apple

An Apple

Host

什么?抱歉?

What? Sorry?

Zeno

对,就像 Apple 会自动给你生成一个邮箱地址。

Yeah, like Apple auto generates an email address for you.

Host

哦,对对对。对对对。

Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Zeno

为了

For

Host

对对,我用过那个。我用过。

Yeah, yeah, I used that. I used that.

Host

这对你们来说是个问题吗?

Is it a problem for you guys?

Zeno

他们对哪些邮件能进收件箱更严格。所以有时候作为域名所有者,我们实际上有个产品内向导,帮你向 Apple 注册,这样你的邮件才能送达那里。

They're more strict in terms of what can get into those inboxes. So sometimes as a domain owner, we actually have like an in-product wizard to help you like register with Apple so that you can get your emails delivered there.

Host

对对。嗯,好。我明白了。显然这是你的工作,对吧?整个事情就是送达率。如果没有送达率,就没有生意,对吧?

Yeah, yeah. Um, okay. I understand. The obviously this is your job, right? The whole thing is deliverability. If you don't have deliverability, you don't have a business, right?

Zeno

对。

Yep.

Host

这大概就是框架。

That's kind of the framework.

Zeno

网站上最漂亮的魔方、最酷的手册,如果宕机了,就全白搭了。

Most beautiful Rubik's Cube in the website, the most like coolest handbook ever if it's down. It's all for nothing.

域名声誉与子域名 Domain reputation and subdomains

Host

它们之间的相关性有多大,对吧?比如如果你在 Google 被封禁或降权,或者被放进促销标签页,这会转移到其他家吗?还是说非常去中心化?

And how correlated are they are they, right? Like if you get banned or down ranked or put in promotions tab in Google, does that transfer over to the other guys or they very decentralized?

Zeno

幸好现在,在电子邮件行业初期,它非常基于 IP,如果一个 IP 池受损,现在你就要承担后果。现在很多声誉与域名关联。所以人们会做的是,根据发送的邮件类型创建不同的子域名。比如一个子域名用于事务性邮件,你知道可能没有点击和打开跟踪,然后另一个域名用于营销邮件。这些子域名有助于隔离声誉,无论

Thankfully now like in the beginning of the email industry, it was very IP based and if one IP pool was damaged like now you you are getting the the consequences of that. Now there's a lot of reputation associated with the domain. So then what people do is uh you create different subdomains depending on what type of emails you're sending. Like one subdomain for transactional emails that you know that maybe doesn't have click and open tracking and then you have another domain for your marketing emails. And those subdomains help segregate the reputation of whatever

Host

这会是像 transactions.resent.com 还是

Is this would it be like transactions.resent.com or

Zeno

更新、通知,随便你想用什么。呃

Updates, notifications, whatever you want to use it. Uh

Host

如果我想用 a.b.c.resent.com,可以有更多点吗?

And do I have more dots if I want like a.b.c.resent.com?

Zeno

可以,但我们看到,做,我不知道,五个子域名,对,不太实际,但人们确实会,对,一些特殊的。比如我们在 resent 自己的邮件就这么做。营销有不同于事务性的流,对,甚至投资者那个也有不同的,比如我用那个最近的机密账户发那些邮件。

You could do, but we just see like uh doing I don't know, five subdomains is like yeah, not not really practical, but like people do uh yeah, like some special ones. Like we do that at resent for our own emails. Like marketing has a different stream than the transactional ones and yeah, even the the investor one has a different, like a I used confidential that recent account to send those emails.

Host

甚至不知道你可以,对,那是个好建议。

Didn't even know you could yeah and that that is a good advice.

Zeno

这是个好做法。

It's a good practice.

Host

非常基于 IP,现在非常基于域名。

Very IP based now it's very domain based.

域名选择与钓鱼 Domain choice and phishing

Host

你知道我有,好吧,我收到太多坏的,我得单独买一个,因为我们用 ai.engineer 和他们 turn.space,都是没人认识的奇怪顶级域名,对吧,所以我被告知要给所有东西买 .com。

You know I have okay I I have received so many bad I have to buy a separate so because we use ai.engineer and they turn dot space it is all like weird TLDs that nobody recognizes right so I was told to get .coms for everything.

Zeno

然后也许那能提高送达率。

And then maybe that improves deliverability.

Host

问题是,现在比如拿可口可乐来说,可口可乐有一个域名,现在你是可口可乐,然后说哦对,我们买另一个看起来像我们域名的域名。

The problem with that is that now like let's say let's take Coca-Cola right Coca-Cola has a domain now you're Coca-Cola and like oh yeah let's buy another domain that looks like our domain.

Zeno

看起来像钓鱼。

It looks like phishing.

Host

看起来完全像钓鱼,所以损害的可能性更糟。

It looks exactly like phishing so the chances of damage is way worse.

Host

买 .com 时这还是个事吗?比如我反过来理解,你是 latentspace.com,我买 latent.space 看起来像钓鱼,对吧,但是

Is this still a thing when you're buying the .com? Like I would get it the other way right you're latentspace.com I buy latent.space looks like phishing right but

Zeno

对。

Yeah.

Host

.com 还是?

The .com still?

Zeno

老兄,你会惊讶的,我每天看到的事情简直疯狂。

Man you would be surprised like there's just like the things I see on a day-to-day basis is like crazy.

Host

对。

Yeah.

Host

对,所以我听到的是 .com 值得。

Yeah so what I'm hearing is that .com is worth it.

Zeno

对。

Yeah.

AEO与内容策略 AEO and content strategy

Host

这就是邮件业务的那部分。显然其中一部分是你在 ChatGPT 之前就开始了,然后你是一个人们喜欢的领先玩家,然后显然有机地你出现了,你没有为 AEO 做任何特别的事。

That's all the sort of business of email. Obviously some part of it is you just got started before ChatGPT and then you were a leading player that people liked and then obviously organically you you pop up you didn't do anything special for AEO.

Zeno

嗯哼。

Uh-huh.

Host

你为 AEO 做了什么?

What did you do for AEO?

Zeno

我想说我们不是领导者,因为我们在 2023 年崛起时,很少有人知道 recent,我们远远落后于 Twilio、Postmark、Mailgun,那些公司在 SEO 上投资了 10 多年,所以我们要在任何排名上几乎是一场艰苦的战斗,非常非常困难,所以我们做的是,好吧,让我们专注于文档,文档非常有意地,好吧,如果我们做文档,它又有长尾。比如哦,这里有一个文档,不只是 Python,比如如何用 Django 设置。

I would say we were not the leaders because we coming up like in 2023 like very few people knew about recent and we were like so behind Twilio, Postmark, Mailgun those companies invested in SEO for 10 plus years so for us to get ranked for anything was like almost like it's it was a uphill battle like so so difficult so then what we did was like okay let's focus on the docs for sure and the docs was very intentional about like okay if we're doing a docs on it has long tail again. Like oh, here's a docs on uh not just Python, like how you set it up with Django.

Host

对,如何用某某做某某。如何用某某做某某。

Yeah, how to blah with blah. How to blah with blah.

Zeno

超短文章专注于

Super short articles focused on

Host

传统 SEO。

Traditional SEO.

Zeno

传统 SEO,呃,没什么花哨的。然后当模型开始出现时,我想好吧,也许我得改变页面内容,因为如果人们在问问题,那我需要创建以行动和答案、问答格式的内容。所以现在很多 FAQ,几乎 Recent 的每个页面都有 FAQ,你知道。比如去定价页面或者,对。当然,定价几乎总是有 FAQ。

Traditional SEO, uh nothing fancy there. And then when models started to come, then I was like okay, maybe I got to change the content of the page because if people are asking questions, then I need to like create content that is in action and answer ask and answer type of format. So a lot of FAQs now almost every page at Recent has an FAQ, you know. Like you know, go to pricing page or like yeah. Of course, pricing almost always has an FAQ.

Host

挺标准的。对。对对。

Is pretty standard. Yeah. Yeah, yeah.

Zeno

但就像你在各种地方做 FAQ,对。我想也许安全也有,对。所以你看,这是一个模式,所有页面都有,因为人们就是这样问的。Recent 符合 SOC 2 吗?然后答案就在那里。然后好,现在我们有这些东西了,好,现在我们要做 LLMs.txt。所以我们在文档上加了 LLMs.txt,幸好因为我们用的 Mantlified,很棒的产品。我们说好,怎么把这个也带到营销网站。所以每个营销页面都有 LLMs.txt。文档也一样,井号标记,呃,文档的 markdown 版本。我要为网站上的每一个页面做 markdown 版本,营销网站上的。那就是

But like you do FAQs in like all sorts of yeah. I think maybe security also yeah. So like you see it's like a pattern uh of like all pages have that because that's how people are asking. Is Recent SOC 2 compliant? And then just have the answer right there. And then okay, now we have those things in okay, now we got to do LLMs.txt. So we added LLMs.txt on our docs, thankfully because of Mantlified that we use, great product. And we're like okay, how we take this to the marketing site too. So then LLMs.txt for every marketing page. Same with the docs hatch mark uh markdown versions of the docs. I'm going to do markdown versions of every single page on the website, on the marketing website. And that's

Host

内容嗅探还是你只是附加 .md?

Content sniffing or you just append like .md?

Zeno

对,只是附加,你附加,呃,所以如果你去,对,安全页面 .md,它会工作。

Yeah, just append you you do append uh so if you go to the yeah, security page .md, it will work.

Host

对。

Yeah.

Zeno

但如果你对该页面做内容协商,呃,它会在那个页面上渲染 markdown 版本,而不用去

But also if you do content negotiation with that page, uh it will render on that page like the markdown version without going to the

Host

对,对听众来说,这是我不确定是否重要的事情之一。

Yeah, which for listeners, this is one of those things I'm not sure it matters.

Zeno

嗯哼。

Mhm.

定价页准确性 Pricing Page Accuracy

Host

我真的不确定。

I'm really not sure.

Host

是的,我的意思是你做得很好,所以

Yeah, I mean you're winning really well, so

Zeno

是的,我想有一个例子改变了,也许它无助于分发,但有助于准确性。所以去定价页面。我记得那是一个随机的周日,我正在做竞争对手分析,我只是问,好吧,如果你使用 Resend 发送 120 万封电子邮件,并且你用 X、Y 和 Z 竞争对手这样做,谁最便宜,谁最贵?它完全错了。它把最近的搞得一团糟,它实际上说了关于我们的非常糟糕的话,比如,哦,Resend 的定价非常模糊。我当时想,什么鬼,它一点也不模糊。所以这非常令人沮丧。

Yeah, I think well one example that changed uh and maybe it doesn't help with distribution, but helps with accuracy. So go to the pricing page. I remember this was like a random Sunday, and I was just like doing competitor analysis, and I was just asking like, okay, if you send 1.2 million emails using Resend, and you do that with X and Y and Z competitor, who is the cheapest and who is the most expensive? And it got completely wrong. It got the recent one like so bad, and it actually said like very bad things about us like, oh, Resend's pricing is very obscure. I was like, what the Like, it's not obscure at all. So it was like super frustrating.

Host

哦,所以你做了一个计算器。

Oh, so you made a calculator.

Zeno

是的。所以问题是,你知道,智能体不会真的拖拽 JavaScript 小部件。

Yeah. So the problem was, you know, agents don't really drag JavaScript widget.

Host

好的。

Okay.

Zeno

所以然后我所做的是这个页面的 .md 版本,顺便说一下,它有大量的访问量。就像现在

So then what I did was the .md version of this page, which has a tremendous amount of access by the way. Like now like

Host

我看到你对此有分析。

I see you get analytics on this.

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

是的,是的。好的。

Yeah, yeah. Okay.

Zeno

也不是通过常规的分析点,因为就像我们无法追踪那个,所以然后我们得去 DataDog 弄清楚。

Not through the regular analytics spots too, because like we cannot track that So then like we got to go to DataDog to figure that out.

Host

哦,好的。

Oh, okay.

Zeno

天哪,这真的很疯狂。就像然后我做了那个改变。我推送了它,然后几天后我又问了一次,然后它得到了正确的数字。

And man, it was really crazy. Like and then I made that change. I pushed that, and then I asked again like a few days later, and then it got the numbers right.

Host

我明白了。

I see.

Zeno

所以我想,好吧,这已经

So I'm like, okay, this already

Host

实时更新和修复搜索引擎中的东西的方法。

way to live update and fix stuff in your search engine.

Zeno

而这才是重要的,对吧?就像,好吧,准确性。

And and this is what matters, right? Like, okay, accuracy.

Host

确实意味着你没有单一的事实来源。就像你必须更新 MD,然后你还必须更新

does mean that you don't have a single source of truth. Like you have to update the MD, and then you also have to update the

Zeno

那完全糟糕。但再次,如果我想要快乐路径和简单路径,我就不会做电子邮件。所以我想,这就是代价

That sucks completely. But again, if if I wanted the happy path and the easy path, like I wouldn't be doing email. So I'm like, that's the price of like

Host

嗯,你知道,如果你擅长 React,你可以写一个自定义渲染器,就像是的,你知道如何做这个。是的。

Well, you know, if you're good at React, you can write a custom renderer that like yeah, you you know how to do this. Yeah.

Zeno

还有什么?我们谈了基线,基本上到处都有 FAQ,基本的 SEO 东西。

What else? We talked baselines, basically have FAQ everywhere, basic SEO stuff.

Host

页面?我们对比 SendGrid,我们对比 Mailchimp。

pages? Us versus SendGrid, us versus Mailchimp.

Zeno

我们的可以好得多。去去

our Our could be much better. Go go

Host

是的,我知道这不在那里。我的意思是,我确信你在某个页脚或其他地方有它。

Yeah, I know this is not there. I mean, I'm sure you have it somewhere in some footer or something or whatever.

Zeno

是的。只需做斜杠迁移。我可以给你一些

Yeah. Just do slash migrate. I can can give you some

Host

顺便说一句,404 页面,我总是认为我们应该猜测。你知道,取 slug

By the way, 404 pages, I always think we should guess. You know, take the slug

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

邻居。

neighbors.

Zeno

哦,是的。

Oh, yeah.

Host

好的。

Okay.

Host

我的意思是,我认为有一个网站

I mean, I I think there's a site

Host

以防你曾经破坏 URL,就像它会自动修复自己,对吧?你不只是提供 404。

In case you ever break ever break a URL, like it just auto fixes itself, right? You don't you don't don't just serve the 404.

Zeno

我对那些的意图是,哦,让我尝试做一些不完全是比较页面的东西。但我不认为这是一个好主意,因为我们的竞争对手实际上建立了比较页面,它们比我们的更受推荐。但我们尝试做的是,例如,如果你去 Postmark,就像,好吧,让我们先演示,嘿,如果你想迁移,这里有一个代码转换器。呃

My intention with those is like, oh, let me try to do something that's not exactly like a comparison page. But I don't think it was a great idea because it our competitors actually built the comparison pages and they get recommended more than ours. But what we try to do like if you go to Postmark, for example, is like, okay, let's demonstrate first like, hey, you if you want to migrate, here's a code converter. Uh

Host

插入示例。

Insert example.

Zeno

是的。所以如果你只是在那里放任何代码块

Yeah. So if you just put any code code block there

Host

为什么为什么?

Why why?

Zeno

为什么,伙计?为什么?

Why, dude? Why?

Zeno

这就是我们所做的。这就是我们所做的。

That's what we do. That's what we do.

Host

这太额外了。

This is so extra.

Zeno

每个着陆页上都有一个立方体。一切都是额外的。

Every there's a cube on the landing page. Everything's extra.

Host

立方体是额外的。

The cube is extra.

Zeno

但就像采用率是我上个周末推动的。就像现在我们有一个图表,比较我们与每个不同竞争对手的采用率。你看到一件事,再次,这是我从定价页面学到的教训。JavaScript 小部件,它们不会被执行的。所以我把相同的数据用文本拼写出来,以便 LLMs 实际上可以读取那个东西。所以

But like the the adoption is one that I pushed this last weekend. Like now we have a graph that compares like our adoption with every different competitor. And you you see one thing like again, this was a lesson that I learned with the pricing page. JavaScript widgets, they're not going to be executed. So I spell out the same data in text so that LLMs can actually read that thing. So

Host

我认为它们变得好一些了。我看到很多智能体式使用。好的,加载网站,点击图像,解释图像。它更慢,但

I think they're getting somewhat better. I see a lot of agentic use. Okay, load load website, click on image, interpret image. It's slower, but

Zeno

是的。但有了计算机使用,它们变得好多了。我同意。但如果你在获取信息并且只是比较东西,它们不会那样做,对吧?

Yeah. But with computer use, they are getting much better. I agree. But if you're fetching information and you're just comparing stuff, they don't they don't do that, right?

Host

我认为它们开始更多地

I think they're starting to go more

Host

计算机使用。我一直在做很多比较这个和这个,网站的浏览器是相当计算机使用的。

computer use. I've been doing a lot of compare this and this and the browser of website is pretty computer use.

Zeno

好的。

Okay.

Host

是的。

Yeah.

Host

我注意到你没有,呃,你知道另一个经典的 AEO 策略是,这里是如何将我们的东西与 Claude Code 连接。这里是如何将我们的东西与 Codex 连接。

I noticed that you don't have like uh you know another classic AEO tactic is like here's how to connects our thing with Claude Code. Here's how to connect our thing with Codex.

Zeno

哦好的。

Oh okay.

Zeno

是的,我们这样做。

Yeah, we do that.

Host

好的。

Okay.

Zeno

有一些有趣的事情,比如如果你去法律页面,所以最近的账户/法律在任何一个这些,比如哦总结或要求解释呃

There are some things that are interesting like if you go to the legal page, so recent account/legal in any one of these like oh summarize or ask to explain uh

Host

Plexity。

Plexity.

Zeno

我看到那只是一个外部链接。是的,是的,是的。

I see that's just an external link. Yeah yeah yeah.

Host

是的,我再次不确定那是否重要,但我

Yeah, I again not sure that matters but I

Host

你提到了很多关于 AEO 相对于传统 SEO 的时新性,所以

You mentioned a lot about recency for AEO compared to traditional SEO, so

Zeno

是的,那是我一开始非常好奇的事情。就像任何模型都没有理由推荐我们,因为我们在 SEO 方面太落后了。我们没有典型的词汇表页面或其他类似的东西,或者那些非常通用、只是 SEO 重的文章。我试图揭示那是什么,我可以完全看出,至少对于 Opus 4.5,在技术和他们获取数据的地方存在时新性偏差。我知道最近他们说也许 Raplet 不一定是人们建议的东西了,但肯定是更新的工具,它们开始更频繁地出现,而 recent 是其中之一。因为有很多,我不知道,关于该工具的自然内容,然后我们会得到更多推荐。所以这里的建议就是尝试让尽可能多的人,在尽可能多的地方谈论产品,因为它肯定有影响。

Yeah, that was my the the thing that I was super uh curious about uh in the beginning. Like there was no reason for any of the models to recommend us because we're so behind in SEO. We we don't have the typical glossary page or whatever like or articles that are so generic that were just like SEO heavy. And I was trying to uncover like what what is that and I could totally tell like uh at least with Opus 4.5 there was a recency bias in terms of the the technology and where they were fetching data. I know recently like they said like maybe Raplet is not necessarily um something that people suggest anymore, but definitely like newer tools uh they started popping more and recent was one of those. And because there was a lot of I don't know organic content about the tool then we would be getting recommended more. So the advice here is just like try to get as more people in in more places to talk about the product as possible because it definitely influences.

Host

显然我认为那是其中的一类。我猜你曾经聘请过 SEO 顾问、AEO 顾问吗?它们有用吗?它们是浪费钱吗?

Obviously I think that is uh class of it. I guess did you ever engage SEO consultants, AEO consultants? Are they useful? Are they waste of money?

Zeno

我们从未真正这样做过。

We never really did that.

Host

你只是自己做一切。

you're just doing everything yourself.

Zeno

想你 是的。

think you Yeah.

Host

你是一条 2024 年关于 AEO 的推文,我想你是最早接受它的人之一,你知道吗?

You're an AEO 2024 tweet of talk about I think you were one of the first ones to to pick it up, you know?

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

我的意思是,我认为人们普遍对事情的状况,因为我们当时做了一个关于 AEO 或 GEO 的节目,大多数人都说就像做正常的 SEO 一样,不要阻止 AI 聊天机器人。我想然后大多数工具,比如当时的 Profound,它们只是跟踪你的提及,然后让你做实验等等。

I mean, I think people generally the state of things because we did an AEO or GEO episode at the time around this stuff and most people were like just do what normal SEO does and don't block AI chatbots. I think and then most most tools like Profound at at the time they would just like track your mentions and then you know let you do experiments and all those things.

AEO实验与内容优势 AEO Experiments and Content Advantage

Zeno

所有这些事情都是意料之中的,很正常。我只是在尝试——显然人们在联系我,因为我也在做 AEO 实验,研究该怎么做。我有一个不公平的优势,因为我做的是内容业务。所以我显然会大量产出内容,而你实际上有一个产品。

All those things are par for the course and normal. I'm just trying to—obviously people are pinging me because I'm also doing AEO experiments on what to do. I have an unfair advantage because I'm a content business. So obviously I pump out content, whereas you actually have a product.

Host

但所以是的。这对你来说有多重要?你非常获胜,但你有多关注我们的文档被使用得如何,与竞争对手相比我们被推荐的频率如何?

But so yeah. How important is it to you too? Like you're very winning, but how much do you keep track of how well our docs are used, how often are we recommended compared to competitors like?

Zeno

天哪,我觉得这太关键了,因为以前如果我们对用哪个工具有点不确定,我们会问谷歌,然后你会看到那些对比页面,或者你会看到前三个回答,而现在你一开始就只得到一个回答,对吧?如果你在问该用哪个工具。而且是的,人们只想选择最无障碍的那个。

Man, I feel it's so crucial because before, if we're like a little bit unsure about which tool to use, we would ask Google and then you would get to like those comparison pages or you would get to like the first three responses, and now you just get the one response out of the gate, right? If you're asking which tool should I use. And yeah, people just want to go with the one that is the most frictionless.

Host

是的,我认为免费套餐非常重要,而且我觉得 WorkOS 的 Michael Greenwich 正在推广这个 MD 的想法,对吧?我不知道你们有没有见过。所以这个想法,它和 Netlify 也很相似,你不需要账户就能做基本操作。所以这就像是你产品的未认证使用,显然这很危险,因为它容易被滥用,但它是像无需注册的最简单方式。

Yeah, which I think free tier is very important and um I think uh Michael Greenwich from WorkOS is trying to promote this idea of MD, right? I don't know if you guys have seen it. So so uh the idea that you it's very similar to Netlify as well where you don't need an account to do the basic action. So it's like unauthenticated usage of your product which is very dangerous obviously because it's prone to abuse, but uh it is the easiest like no sign up.

Zeno

是的,那就是我在尝试的——是的,我在考虑要不要这么做。我们需要一个配置 API 吗?我一直在反复思考这个,比如好吧,把这个叫做——

Yeah, that's the thing that I'm trying—yeah, I'm debating doing that or not. Do we need a provisioning API? And I keep going back and forth on this like okay, call this—

Host

配置和声明,对吧?这样可以吗?

Provisioning and claims, right? Is that okay?

Zeno

配置和声明。但然后免费套餐,是的,我不知道是不是我们行业的特点,但会有——

Provisioning and claims. But then free tier yeah like I don't know if it's something about our industry, but there's—

Host

你只会遇到滥用。是的。

You just have abuse. Yeah.

Zeno

我有很多滥用。

I just have a lot of abuse.

Host

是的,好的。是的,我的意思是,我认为那些是主要策略。我想告诉听众思考的另一件事是,直接把你的 clanker 连接到你的分析和代码库,对吧?就像你需要完全完成闭环,然后基本上自动研究。对吧?就像这个网站,所以我现在有的是我的循环。我有两个——我有一个潜在空间 CMO 智能体和一个 AIE CMO 智能体,对吧?它们会生成其他智能体,或者它们的工作是研究想法,跟踪我们尝试过的事情,然后我批准我们想要实验的事情。我们有一个实验窗口。我们去做实验,然后那些是其他智能体,然后由它们监控。所以我会说这就像是做这些事情的自动研究循环。我想然后你还需要给它工具。所以我批准 Ahrefs。我批准 data for SEO。

Yeah, okay. Yeah, I mean I think those are the main tactics. I think the other thing that I would just tell listeners to think about is literally hook your clanker up to your analytics and your codebase, right? Like you need to fully complete the loop and then basically auto research. Right? Like this site like so what I have now is my cycle. I have both—I have a latent space CMO agent and I have an AIE CMO agent, right? And they spawn other agents or like their job is to research ideas, keep track of things that we've tried, well and then I sign off on things that we want to experiment. We have an experiment window. We go and do the experiments and then those are other agents that then monitored are monitored by them. And so I would say that's like kind of like the auto research loop for doing this stuff. I think then you also need to give it tools. So like I sign off for Ahrefs. I sign off for data for SEO.

Host

哦是的。

Oh yeah.

Zeno

然后最近我做了我自己的 AIO 追踪器,你也可以做。

And then uh most recently I made my own AIO tracker which you can make.

Host

是的。

Yep.

Zeno

嗯,然后是的,你只想让数字上升。

Um and then yeah you just want to make the number go up.

Host

是的,当然。这就像你不知道,对吧?就像你在往墙上扔东西。这就是为什么,是的,法律页面上的东西,那重要吗?我不知道,但我会继续往墙上扔东西,看看什么——

Yeah, for sure. And it's like you don't know, right? Like you're throwing things at the wall. That's why like yeah the thing on the legal page, does that matter? I have no idea, but I will keep throwing things at the wall and seeing what—

Zeno

我觉得 Reddit 不重要,Hacker News。你以前在 Hacker News 上很重要,现在不那么重要了。

I think like uh Reddit doesn't matter, Hacker News. You used to be big on Hacker News, not less.

Host

是的,不再重要了。

Yeah, not anymore.

Zeno

Twitter 也没那么重要了。

Twitter doesn't matter as much.

Host

是的。

Yeah.

Zeno

这很奇怪,就像对吧——

It's weird, like right like—

Host

太疯狂了。

So crazy.

Zeno

你有追踪器吗?

Do you have a tracker?

Host

不,我们用了世界上所有那些 Profound 之类的。还有其他产品。所以我们全都试过了。就像人们问我,哦我应该用 Godge 还是 Profound 还是这个那个?我说,是的,我们有四个订阅。你知道,现在就是这样。你得看看哪个最有效。我从那些工具中缺少的是给我行动。我觉得问题是,它们不告诉你该做什么,因为它们也在试图弄清楚需要发生什么,对吧?比如,哦,在维基百科上写一篇文章,是的。

No, like we use all of those profounds of the world. Uh there are other products. So we tried them all. Like people ask me like, oh should I use Godge or Profound or this other one? I'm like, yeah we have four subscriptions. You know like that that's what it takes now. Like you got to see which one works best. What I miss from those tools is like give me the action. And I think the problem, they don't give you like what to do, because they're also trying to figure out what needs to happen, right? Like, oh, write an article on Wikipedia, like yeah.

Zeno

是的,我会说像 Moz 和所有那些老派的 SEO 工具,它们实际上会对这些事情有更多观点。现在,据我所知,SEO 工具大多——再次,我不是专家,我们可能应该和 Profound 谈谈——它们只是报告工具,对吧?和分析报告工具。那没关系。这是一个大生意。Ahrefs 是一家新加坡企业,显然他们做大概,我不知道,3 亿到 4 亿美元。

Yeah, I would say like the old school SEO tools like Moz and all those kinds, they would actually have more opinionation around these things. Right now, the SEO tools mostly from what I hear, again, I'm not an expert, we should probably talk to Profound, is that they just are reporting tools, right? And the analytics reporting tools. And uh that's fine. It's a big business. Ahrefs is a Singapore business, and apparently they do like I don't know, $3 $400 million.

Host

是的,完全正确。嗯哼。

Yeah, totally. Uh-huh.

企业销售与文化 Enterprise Sales and Culture

Host

你业务的其他部分,比如我们要谈谈育儿方面和个人方面。我真的想说,好吧,你看起来很冷静,你有 50 个人在世界各地远程工作,你在担心 MCP,你在担心 AEO。这不可能是你关闭所有这些大客户的方式,对吧?比如,你那个带着牛排晚餐和高尔夫球场的花哨销售员在哪里?

The other parts of your business, like we're going to talk about like the parenting side and personal side. I just really want to be like, okay, you seem very chill, you have 50 people remote all around the world, you are worrying about MCP, you're worrying about AEO. That cannot be the way you're closing all these big customers, right? Like, where's your fancy sales guy with the steak dinner and the golf course?

Zeno

我们才刚刚开始那个动作。而且我认为我们非常幸运,能够在没有那个动作的情况下走到这一步。我过去在一家只做企业业务的公司工作过,所以我知道那需要什么。还有牛排晚餐,就像销售组织周围的所有机构,赋能,所有这些我需要的东西。我知道,好吧,当时机成熟时,我们将不得不打开那个开关。但我一直非常谨慎地在最近做这件事,就像在不同层次,而不是只是增加 20 个。我很——也许是因为我们远程,但我认为我们非常保护文化。比如,让我们确保不要一下子破坏文化。所以不,让我们试着找到合适的人。所以我们现在只有一个 AE,它一直在帮助,它一直是的,进展非常顺利。

We're just starting that motion. Uh and I think we are very lucky that we're able to go this far without having that motion. I've worked at an enterprise-only company in the past, so I knew what does that take. And the steak dinners, like all the apparatus around like that sales org, the enablement, there's all these things that I needed. I knew that, okay, when the time is right, we're going to have to turn on that key. But I've been very cautious about doing that at recent, like in different layers, instead of just like add 20. I'm very maybe it's because we are remote, but I think we are very protective about the culture. Like, let's make sure we don't damage the culture at once. So no, let's try to figure out people who fit. So we just have one AE now, and it's been helping, it's been yeah, going super well.

Host

是的,够好了。我会说,我认为,你知道,一旦你因为几笔交易而年经常性收入翻倍,你会说,好吧,这很好。

Yeah, good enough. I would say I think, you know, once you have like you know, you double your ARR because of like a couple deals, you're like, okay, like this is a good.

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

因为人们想为那些东西付你更多钱,你会说,好吧,你知道,我有和你的协议,我有你的软件在我的场所或在我的 VPC 里,随便什么,对吧?嗯,所以。

Cuz people want to pay you more for things that that you're like okay, well, you know, I have like the agreement with you, I have like your software on my premises or in my VPC, whatever, right? Um so.

Zeno

当然。是的。而且我也在学到的是,你在构建一个不同的产品。所以这就是你需要看待它的方式。这不仅仅是我在公司内部构建一个不同的机器。当我在设计公司时,我在设计,好吧,哪个部门,谁坐在哪里,每个人如何更好地装备来做他们的工作。不,对于企业来说,它实际上是一个不同的产品。他们关心什么与 20 美元用户关心什么非常不同。如果我只是添加,你知道,WorkOS 和 SSO 和 SCIM 和审计日志,那是不够的。

For sure. Yeah. And what I'm learning too is like you're building a different product. So that's what how you need to see it. It's not only I'm building a different machine internally as a company. As I'm designing the company, I'm designing okay, which department, who sits where, how each person is better equipped to do their job. No, like for enterprise, it's actually a different product. Like what do they care is very different from what $20 users care. And if I just add, you know, work OS and SSO and and scam and audit logs, it's not going to be enough.

定价与邮件发送 Pricing and Email Sending

Host

所以这不仅仅是把那些项目放在定价页面上。所以这肯定是一个过程。

So it's not just putting those items on the pricing page. So it's a journey for sure.

Host

在我们进入个人方面之前,你还想回顾一下这段旅程的其他事情吗?

Any other things you want to reflect on the journey before we go into the personal side?

Zeno

不,我想不用了,我们已经涵盖了很多内容。

No, I think no, we covered a lot of ground.

Host

哦好的,那我来谈谈我的使用场景,对吧?比如我是一个内容创作者,对吧?我假设你业务的大部分是事务性邮件。我可能可以查一下

Oh okay, then I'll talk a little bit about my use case, right? Like I'm a content creator, right? You're the bulk of your business, I assume is transactional email. I probably could look it up by

Zeno

没错。

That's right.

Host

你有营销邮件,你有入站邮件。我确定那可能不太算在业务内。我每年付给 Substack 大约 1 万美元

You have marketing emails, you have inbound emails. I'm sure that's like sort of less outside of the business. I pay Substack something like $10,000 a year

Zeno

嗯哼。

Uh-huh.

Host

来发送我的邮件。那似乎太高了。

to send my emails. And that seems too high.

Zeno

是的。

Yeah.

Host

所以我想,为什么营销邮件和事务性邮件如此不同?

So I think like why is marketing email versus transactional email so different?

Zeno

这是个好问题。嗯

It's a great question. Um

Host

因为你的商业模式也不同,对吧?如果你

Cuz your business model's also different, right? If you

Zeno

是的。是的。

It is. It is.

Host

而且这实际上

And like this actually

Zeno

也更贵。

are more expensive too.

Host

是的,然后我就想我不能这么做。

Yeah, then I was like I can't do this.

Zeno

是的,这个行业有按联系人收费的模式。这是第一点。所以他们试图围绕每个联系人创造的价值来定价。但现在很疯狂,比如我们服务的 AI 公司,它们增长如此之快,比如 Mistral 使用 recent。好吗?所以他们增加的用户数量简直疯狂。所以按联系人定价的商业模式有点被打破了,我们意识到这一点并试图解决。但这一直是这样,而且当你发送事务性邮件时,就像把消息放入队列然后出队列。对于营销邮件,你是在构建那个引擎,比如批次和批次之间的间隔,分析,在发送过程中增加速度、降低速度,可能阻止。所以

Yeah, the industry has this pattern of like charging per contact. That's the first thing. So the way they try to price is around the value you create in each contact. But now it's crazy like the AI companies that we serve, they grow so fast, like Mistral uses recent. Okay? So they're like the amount of users that they add is just insane. So like the business model of contact-based pricing is kind of broken and we are realizing that and trying to fix that too. But that's how it had always been and there's something about like when you send a transactional email, it's just like put a message in a queue and get out of the queue. With marketing email, you're building that engine of like batches and intervals between batches, analyzing, increasing the speed, decreasing the speed as the sending is going, maybe blocking. So

Host

一次发送邮件有最大速率吗?

Is there a max rate you should send emails at a time?

Zeno

是的,当然。特别是每个域名。是的。

Yeah, for sure. Per domain specifically. Yeah.

Host

好的。那么假设我有 10 万封邮件要发送,应该花我 10 分钟?

Okay. So like let's say I have 100k emails to send out, it should take me 10 minutes?

Zeno

是的。例如,现在我们拥有 430 万用户,需要超过一天的时间。

Yeah. And it For example, now with the 4.3 million users that we have, it takes more than a day.

Host

然后你 哦,什么?不,那不可接受。

then you Oh, what? No, that's unacceptable.

Zeno

是的,当然。

Yeah, for sure.

Host

那么我付你更多钱进入不同的队列?

So then I pay you more to get in a different queue?

Zeno

是的。所以你必须总是试图弄清楚,好的,我们需要更多在门口。那么这是如何运作的?嗯

Yeah. So you have to be like always trying to figure out, okay, we need more at the door. So how does that work? Uh

Host

是的,是的,是的。哦,那很有趣。就像速率限制,比如说令牌限制。

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Oh, that's interesting. It's like rate limits for let's say token limits.

Zeno

是的。没错。

Yeah. Exactly.

Host

我的重置按钮在哪里?

Where's my reset button?

Zeno

是的,没错。

Yeah, exactly.

与家人共同创业 Founding with a Family

Host

你还像你进入 YC,你作为一个年轻父亲创办了这家公司。我认为部分原因是旧金山有很多没有孩子的人。我认为这是考虑的一部分。我想很多听众会想,我不能成为创始人。比如我有这个好主意,但我有年轻家庭。你是怎么管理的?

You also like you went into YC, you started this company as a young father. And I think like part of the things like there are a lot of no kids people in in SF. And I think that's part of the consideration. I think a lot of people are listening who are like, I can't be a founder. Like I have this great idea, but like I got I got young family. How do you manage?

Zeno

呃,你得先说明你离开旧金山是为了

Uh you got to preface with you've left SF for

Host

是的。

Yeah.

Zeno

孩子。是的。所以这是最近的消息。比如现在在巴西花更多时间,因为我们即将迎来第二个孩子。我想一开始,天啊,太疯狂了,因为我来到旧金山时,我女儿 1 岁。我周围的每个 YC 创始人都不知 道,是的,有孩子意味着什么

kids. Yeah. So this is the recent news. Like spending more time in Brazil now because we're expecting our second kid. And I think at first, man, it was crazy because I came to SF, my daughter was 1 year old. And every YC founder around me had no idea like yeah, what does it mean to have

Host

是的。这是什么繁殖?你连 B 轮都没有。比如,你结婚在做什么?比如

Yeah. What is this reproduction? You don't even have series B. Like, what are you doing married? Like

Zeno

完全正确。他们大多数根本没结婚。这很疯狂,嗯,我想再次,我总是试着看待这些事情。一开始,你把他们视为优势,比如,天啊,所有这些家伙来自 MIT,所有那些了不起的学校。我不是这样。哦,他们没有,他们没有结婚。我不是这样。他们没有孩子。我不是这样。但仍然参加那个项目,我想,天啊,我只想在这个批次中建立最好的公司。不是第四,不是第五,而是 250 个中的第一。

Totally. Most of them weren't married at all. And it's crazy how um I think it again, I always try to look at those things. At first, you see them as a the advantage like, oh man, all of these guys they went from like they came from MIT, all these amazing schools. That was not the case for me. Oh, they don't have they they are not married. That's not the case for me. They don't have kids. That's not the case for me. But still going for that program, I'm like, man, I'm I just want to build the best company on this batch. Not number four, not number five, like number one out of the 250.

Host

哦,是吗?呃,哪个批次?

Oh, yeah? Uh which cohort?

Zeno

2023 年冬季。

Winter 2023.

Host

好的。

Okay.

Zeno

你在这中间意识到 YC 没有赢家。没有这种事。嗯

You realize in the middle of that is that there's no winner in YC. That there's no such thing. Uh

Host

是的,但是像

Yeah, But like

Zeno

我现在拉一个 23 年冬季的名单,看看我认识谁。

I'm pulling a winter 23 now just to see who I know.

Host

是的。

Yeah.

Zeno

尤其是你理解的是,呃

And especially what you understand is that uh

Host

2023 年冬季批次?

Winter 2023 batch?

Zeno

这就像一个无限无限的游戏,对吧?就像那些即使你有一个了不起的批次,你筹集了最大的轮次,也没关系,因为生活继续,我在那里遇到的许多人,他们不再在这里了。

It's like an infinite infinite game, right? Like those even if you had an amazing batch and you raised the biggest round, it doesn't matter because like life goes on and continues and many of the people that I met there, they are not here anymore.

Host

是的。

Yeah.

Zeno

联合创始人分手,七次转型,然后他们死了,对吧?但我们在这里。所以我非常像,不,不,不。我们甚至域名,当我们买了 recent.com 时,就像,不,它会是一个了不起的网站,有一个了不起的 .com。它不会是 .io 或其他什么,对吧?嗯,但带着孩子做那件事真是太难了,特别是因为我想享受我的第一个女儿。我真的想过这个。就像在 YC 期间有一个时刻。所以这个故事就像转化到我要说的。我来到这个活动,PG 在那里。所以我想,天啊,保罗·格雷厄姆,一切之父,神在这里,对吧?所以每个人都在关注 PG。然后他说,你知道吗?我们总是告诉你,不要做这件事。我们作为合伙人告诉你,然后你最终做了这件事,几个月后你来找我们说,哦,我后悔做了或没做这件事。所以他就说了那个。然后我来到我的合伙人面前,我问,好的,我现在做的哪些事情是我不应该做的,你认为错了?然后一个合伙人,不是我的主要合伙人,而是另一个合伙人告诉我,你太担心设计了。你太在意那个了。如果你不在意那个,你会走得更远。现在那伤害我如此之深,因为那是真的。就像我推销时的幻灯片,那是漂亮的幻灯片,他说没关系。我想,是的,现在我知道没关系。但像那样伤害真的很深。然后几天后我在反思那个。我想,是的,但如果我要建立一个有这种身份的产品,只有 1000 人使用,我更喜欢那样,而不是有一个 10000 人的产品,那是一个我不想去、我自己不用的产品。所以你知道吗?我要遵循我认为正确的。我认为在这个行业,再次回到行业,每个人都有糟糕的产品。没有足够的设计融入其中。所以我觉得那是一个差异化因素,我们需要在如此拥挤的市场中有一个差异化因素。

Co-founder breakups, seven pivots, and they're dead, right? But we are here. So I was very much like, no, no, no. We're even the domain when we bought recent.com like, no, it's going to be an amazing website with an amazing .com. Like it's not going to be a .io or whatever, right? Um but doing that with kids was so freaking hard, especially because I wanted to enjoy my my first daughter. And I really thought about this. Like there was one point during YC. So this story like translates to what I'm going to say. I came to this event and PG was there. So I'm like, oh man, Paul Graham, the father of everything, God is here, right? So everyone is paying attention to PG. And then he says, you know what? We always tell you, don't do this thing. We tell you that as partners and then you end up doing the thing and then months later you come to us and say, oh, I regret doing this or not doing this. So he just said that. So then I came to my partners and I asked like, okay, what are the things that I'm doing now that I shouldn't be doing, that you think it's wrong? And then one partner, not my main partner, but another partner told me like, you just worry too much about design. You care too much about that. If you didn't care about that, you will be much further ahead. Now and that hurt me so bad because it was true. Like my slides when I was like pitching it was like a beautiful slides and he's doesn't matter. I'm like, yeah, now I know it doesn't matter. But like that hurt really bad. And then a few days later I was reflecting on that. I'm like, yeah, but if I were to build a product that had like this identity and only 1,000 people used, I prefer doing that than having a product with 10,000 people that it's a product that I don't want to go, that I don't use myself. So you know what? I'm going to follow what I believe is right. And I think in this industry again, going back to the industry, everyone had terrible products. There was not not enough like design infusing to them. So I felt that was a differentiator and we needed a differentiator in such a crowded market.

优先级与权衡 Priorities and Trade-offs

Zeno

所以我也常拿这个来想我的孩子。比如,十年后,我和女儿在一起,她特别想跟我待在一起,我们一直一起玩,而我们的公司营收是 1000 万美元。我宁愿活在那个现实里,也不愿活在一个我们公司值 1 亿美元、但我女儿不想跟我玩、对我不感兴趣、我们关系没那么亲的现实里。这就是我做的决定。也许对,也许错,我也不知道。我拼得非常狠,我有很多野心,这不会让我停下来。但把那些优先级定下来,自己想清楚什么适合我,我觉得这很重要。所以是的,她比以往任何时候都更重要,我很大程度上把她放在优先位置。

So I go back to that for my kid too. Like, okay, 10 years from now, I'm with my daughter and my daughter wants to be with me so much and we play all the time, and we are a 10 million ARR company. I would rather live in that reality than live in a reality where we are a 100 million dollar company and my daughter doesn't want to play with me, isn't interested in me, and we're not that close. So that's the decision I made. Maybe it's right, maybe it's wrong. I have no idea. I go extremely hard. I have a lot of ambition that's not going to stop me or anything. But setting up those priorities and figuring out for yourself what works for me, I think it was important. So yeah, more than ever she's the most important thing for me and I prioritize her a lot.

Host

那你怎么平衡这个和你的野心呢?我也有类似的情况,只是规模小一些。我没有孩子,但我有很多有野心的事,也有一个我应该花时间陪伴的家庭。可当我陪他们的时候,我人不在场。我在看手机,心里想着,哦,我该去审一下 Astro,或者 GPT 6,就好像,你知道,AGI 一样。不,并不是,对吧?但我真的觉得我应该在工作。同时我又觉得内疚,所以我在两边都不开心。

How do you balance that with your ambition, right? Like I also have this in a smaller way. I don't have kids, but yeah, I have a lot of ambitious things and I have a family that I should spend time with, and when I spend time with them, I'm not present. I'm looking at my phone. I'm like saying, oh, I should be reviewing Astro, you know, GPT 6, like it's just like, you know, AGI. No, it's not, right? But I really feel like I should be working. And at the same time I feel guilty, and so I'm unhappy in both areas.

Zeno

完全同意。我就是那种感觉。我觉得自己是个糟糕的爸爸、糟糕的丈夫、糟糕的 CEO,就好像你在生活的每一个领域都在失败。我就是那种感觉,一模一样。但每一天我都试着多一点在场,尤其是你在家办公的时候。天哪,你走出办公室,然后你现在是爸爸了,然后又不是了。哦,现在你得当丈夫,要关注你妻子,而你的脑子却在想,天哪,这个企业级单子怎么做,我得把这笔交易谈下来。我也觉得自己一直像个神经病。我们是一条船上的。

Totally. And that's how I feel. I feel like I'm a terrible dad. I'm a terrible husband. I'm a terrible CEO, and like you're failing in every single area of your life. I feel that way exactly like that. But every day I try to be a little bit more present, you know, and it's especially when you're working from home. Like man, you leave your office and then now you're a dad, and then now you're not anymore. Oh, now you got to be a husband and pay attention to your wife, and your mind is like, oh man, how do I do this enterprise, like I got to close this deal. I feel like I psycho all the time too. We're in the same boat.

品类创建 Category Creation

Host

是啊,是啊。从来都不容易。我觉得为自己的品类命名很重要,而人们真的没有足够重视品类创造。这是 Netlify 试过但用 Jamstack 失败的事情,我觉得更多人真的应该去尝试品类创造,因为一旦成功,他们就拥有整个品类。所以我们最近就做了这个,你知道,它是下一代 SendGrid,可以这么说吧?或者叫 AI 原生的 SendGrid 之类的。

Yeah, yeah. Well, never easy. And I think just naming the thing for your category is important, and people don't really think about category creation enough, I think. This is something Netlify tried to do and failed with Jamstack, and I think more people should really actually try to do a category creation, because when they're successful, then they own the whole thing. So which we did for this recent, you know, it is the next generation SendGrid, let's call it, right? Or like AI native SendGrid or something like that.

Zeno

我觉得,你知道,这可能是我太诚实了,那还不算品类创造,但算是品类主导。你知道,你拥有你的品类,这很好。但差异点还不够清晰。所以我经典的例子是我们请过的另一位嘉宾,HubSpot 的 Dharmesh Shah。

I think that, you know, and this is me being probably too honest, that is not category creation yet, but it is category dominance. You know, like you own your category, that's good. But it is not clear enough yet what the difference is. So my classic example is another guest that we've had, Dharmesh Shah from HubSpot.

Host

是啊。

Yeah.

Zeno

任何想思考品类创造的人,去读一读入站营销与出站营销,以及他们是如何创造出“入站”这个品类的。品类创造的理想境界是,一旦你听到这个品类,也就是你公司代表的那两个词,你就不想要别的了。

Anyone who wants to think about category creation, go and read up about inbound marketing versus outbound marketing and how they created the category of inbound. The ideal phrase of category creation is once you've heard the category, the two words that your company represents, you don't want anything else.

Host

嗯。

Mm.

Zeno

没有长篇大论,没有长篇宣言,没有演讲,就是两个词,也许再加几个例子,就这样。你的受众可以自己往下走。

There's no long essay, there's no long manifesto, there's no talk, it's just two words, maybe some examples, that's it. Your audience can take it from there.

Host

嗯。

Mm.

Zeno

这非常难。

It's very hard.

Host

天哪,我见过 France 试着做那个,比如 Zvix,它是 webhooks 即服务。

Man, I've seen France trying to do that, like Zvix, it's webhooks as a service.

Zeno

是啊,是啊,他们用了我的名字。

Yeah, yeah, they took my name.

Host

是啊,老兄。这真是太难了,对吧?就像

Yeah, man. It's just so freaking hard, right? Like

Zeno

我觉得他们做得还行吧?我不知道他们还在不在。当时有一家 webhooks 公司,然后还有一家反 webhooks 公司。就像你会说,我们不做 webhooks,我们只是帮你发布一个 JSON 文件,你自己去拉取之类的。你知道,它有点反转了推与拉的数据流。是啊,这又是疫情时代的开发者工具。那是当时最令人兴奋的事情。

I think they're doing okay, right? I don't know if they're still around. There was like a webhooks company and then there was like an anti-webhooks company. Like you would take, like you were like, we don't do webhooks, we just help you publish a JSON file that you pull or something like that. You know, like it kind of reverses the push versus pull, the data flow. Yeah, this is again COVID era dev tools. That was the most exciting thing at the time.

Host

对。对。对。

Yep. Yep. Yep.

Host

酷。好吧,每次聊天都很愉快,恭喜你取得的所有成功。我还是很好奇你在你的品类里主导到了什么程度。我觉得你选得非常好,执行得也非常好,而且你还在兼顾家庭。所以非常敬佩。

Cool. Well, always a pleasure to catch up, and congrats on all the success. I still, you know, am very curious how much you have dominated your category. I think you just chose it very well and you executed it very well, and you're managing your family as well. So lots of respect.

Zeno

非常感谢。是啊,和你们聊天很愉快。多谢。

Thanks so much. Yeah, it was great chatting with you guys. Thanks a lot.

互动版:逐字朗读 + 针对本期提问 →